Downsizing, devolution and judicial deferral: a legal-geographical analysis of Butrint National Park, Albania
Purpose Between 2019 and 2025, Butrint National Park, Albania’s earliest World Heritage inscription, saw its protected surface reduced, its archaeological core devolved to a hybrid foundation, and that devolution and a reformed protected-area regime subjected to constitutional review. This study aims to examine how property, planning and environmental law structured these changes and whether the legal record lets affected communities verify that participation influenced them. Design/methodology/approach A single-case design combines doctrinal analysis of the boundary decision, the devolution statute, the amended protected-areas law and two constitutional rulings with rule-based coding of the management plan’s consultation report and UNESCO state-of-conservation documentation. Findings The boundary decision withdrew 8.5% of the park, including portions of the listed site, without published justification. The consultation report answers UNESCO’s Advisory Bodies and academic institutions issue by issue but aggregates municipalities, residents and tourism operators and refers objections to the foundation model for future legislation. The Constitutional Court upheld the devolution by a narrow majority after excluding most claims from its jurisdiction and sustained the reformed regime as framework legislation reviewable only through future zonal decisions. Research limitations/implications Findings generalise analytically; evidence is documentary and singly coded under fixed rules; and land control remains a testable hypothesis. Originality/value This study conceptualises judicial deferral, in which review resolves the case at hand while leaving contested substance to other institutions or later instruments, as a legal-geographical mechanism, operationalises the Aarhus due-account standard as a test of verifiability and proposes a public register of relaxations as well as reductions of protection.
Authors
- Esmiralda Kolaneci (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-3568-3866)
Institutions
- University of Tirana (AL)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Journal of Property Planning and Environmental Law
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1108/jppel-08-2026-0061
- Primary Topic
- Environmental law and policy
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00