Mass Scales of Singularity Resolution: Repulsion, Vacuum Cores and Observational Bounds in Regular Black-Hole Interiors
If matter is not annihilated at a black-hole singularity, something must resist gravitational collapse. We ask what a repulsion built from only three ingredients—the mass M, Newton’s constant G and the mean inter-particle spacing d—can and cannot do, and what current observations allow. Our results are as follows. (i) Gravity per nucleon (10−15–10−11 N) lies 16–20 orders of magnitude below the QCD force scale (1.4 × 105 N); “comparable” holds only for the net force at equilibrium, and the Newtonian comparison fails above 8.3 M⊙. At a horizon, the force needed to hold a nucleon equals the QCD scale at a proper distance ℓc = 1.04 fm for every mass. (ii) Any positive-pressure repulsion obeys Mmax = 0.0851 c 3d 3/2/(G3/2m1/2) (4.07 M⊙ for nuclear onset) and cannot stop collapse beyond it; a bounce requires ρc2 + 3p < 0. (iii) A vacuum-like (p = −ρc2 ) core of density ρG gives horizons only for M ≳ 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ); the existence of 5 M⊙ horizons requires ρG ≳ 5 × 1018 kg m−3 , which is 49 times the hadron-fit QCD bag constant but only 1–13 times other estimates of the QCD vacuum energy. A closed cloud bounces at a = l, at a radius not exceeding (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 (and at most l for release at R0 ≥ Rs): there is no upper mass limit, only a threshold above which the bounce is guaranteed to be hidden. (iv) Quasinormal-mode shifts scale as ≈ 0.08 (l/M) 2 and are not yet constrained by GW250114 (δf220 = 0.02 ± 0.02). (v) A mass-dependent closure l = Rs needs a saturation density falling as M−2 , down to 10−2 kg m−3 for 3.6×1010 M⊙, and therefore cannot be an equation of state. (vi) Any horizonless static object whose energy density never falls below ρG has M < 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ) whatever its pressures, and a thin-shell vacuum-core object obeying the dominant energy condition cannot lie closer than 1.04 Rs (surface redshift ≲ 4). (vii) In QCD-related matter (glueball and gluon gases, flux-tube networks, domain-wall lattices, bag-type vacuum) ρc2 + 3p < 0 needs matter more dilute than the vacuum energy, which compression moves away from. (viii) In an effective loop-quantum-gravity description positive-pressure matter does bounce at ρ ≈ 0.4ρPl, which removes the compression obstacle but makes every exterior signal smaller than 10−80; the bounce time is estimated to grow with mass, so there is no maximum mass. If the bounce time is 4k m2 tP , COBE/FIRAS limits bouncing primordial black holes near M∗ ∼ 1023 kg to f ≲ 4×10−8 of the dark matter and closes the asteroid-mass window; the limit depends on the energy partition and is conditional on the lifetime law (Sec. 9.4). (ix) A homogeneous ground-state core would hold only the fraction (ρ0/ρG) 1/2 of M at the bounce if its boundary were a timelike worldline, and no timelike interface can bounce hidden or hold M > Mcrit, whereas a spacelike transition at RG = (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 conserves the Misner–Sharp mass exactly (Sec. 9.9); the postulated equation of state P = −ρ 2/ρG has c 2 s < 0, and for a Planckian ρG the critical mass is of order the Planck mass (Sec. 9.8). (x) About 91–95% of a nucleon’s mass is QCD field and confinement energy, only ∼ 1% is the bare quark masses (Sec. 4.4). (xi) These conclusions are for a homogeneous, spherical, non-rotating cloud. For an inhomogeneous one the transition front is tilted: with continuous extrinsic curvature the constraint equations forbid a complete conversion to a single ground state, a thin layer that allows it must violate the dominant energy condition, and in the planar limit an extended front must leave an inward residual whose arrival at the centre gives a singularity unless a further mechanism acts; rotation is not covered (Sec. 9.11). A conjectured “mass limit followed by explosion” is not supported.
Authors
- 文正 陈
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24370528
- Primary Topic
- Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
- Type
- preprint