Mass Scales of Singularity Resolution: Repulsion, Vacuum Cores and Observational Bounds in Regular Black-Hole Interiors

If matter is not annihilated at a black-hole singularity, something must resist gravitational collapse. We ask what a repulsion built from only three ingredients—the mass M, Newton’s constant G and the mean inter-particle spacing d—can and cannot do, and what current observations allow. Our results are as follows. (i) Gravity per nucleon (10−15–10−11 N) lies 16–20 orders of magnitude below the QCD force scale (1.4 × 105 N); “comparable” holds only for the net force at equilibrium, and the Newtonian comparison fails above 8.3 M⊙. At a horizon, the force needed to hold a nucleon equals the QCD scale at a proper distance ℓc = 1.04 fm for every mass. (ii) Any positive-pressure repulsion obeys Mmax = 0.0851 c 3d 3/2/(G3/2m1/2) (4.07 M⊙ for nuclear onset) and cannot stop collapse beyond it; a bounce requires ρc2 + 3p < 0. (iii) A vacuum-like (p = −ρc2 ) core of density ρG gives horizons only for M ≳ 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ); the existence of 5 M⊙ horizons requires ρG ≳ 5 × 1018 kg m−3 , which is 49 times the hadron-fit QCD bag constant but only 1–13 times other estimates of the QCD vacuum energy. A closed cloud bounces at a = l, at a radius not exceeding (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 (and at most l for release at R0 ≥ Rs): there is no upper mass limit, only a threshold above which the bounce is guaranteed to be hidden. (iv) Quasinormal-mode shifts scale as ≈ 0.08 (l/M) 2 and are not yet constrained by GW250114 (δf220 = 0.02 ± 0.02). (v) A mass-dependent closure l = Rs needs a saturation density falling as M−2 , down to 10−2 kg m−3 for 3.6×1010 M⊙, and therefore cannot be an equation of state. (vi) Any horizonless static object whose energy density never falls below ρG has M < 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ) whatever its pressures, and a thin-shell vacuum-core object obeying the dominant energy condition cannot lie closer than 1.04 Rs (surface redshift ≲ 4). (vii) In QCD-related matter (glueball and gluon gases, flux-tube networks, domain-wall lattices, bag-type vacuum) ρc2 + 3p < 0 needs matter more dilute than the vacuum energy, which compression moves away from. (viii) In an effective loop-quantum-gravity description positive-pressure matter does bounce at ρ ≈ 0.4ρPl, which removes the compression obstacle but makes every exterior signal smaller than 10−80; the bounce time is estimated to grow with mass, so there is no maximum mass. If the bounce time is 4k m2 tP , COBE/FIRAS limits bouncing primordial black holes near M∗ ∼ 1023 kg to f ≲ 4×10−8 of the dark matter and closes the asteroid-mass window; the limit depends on the energy partition and is conditional on the lifetime law (Sec. 9.4). (ix) A homogeneous ground-state core would hold only the fraction (ρ0/ρG) 1/2 of M at the bounce if its boundary were a timelike worldline, and no timelike interface can bounce hidden or hold M > Mcrit, whereas a spacelike transition at RG = (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 conserves the Misner–Sharp mass exactly (Sec. 9.9); the postulated equation of state P = −ρ 2/ρG has c 2 s < 0, and for a Planckian ρG the critical mass is of order the Planck mass (Sec. 9.8). (x) About 91–95% of a nucleon’s mass is QCD field and confinement energy, only ∼ 1% is the bare quark masses (Sec. 4.4). (xi) These conclusions are for a homogeneous, spherical, non-rotating cloud. For an inhomogeneous one the transition front is tilted: with continuous extrinsic curvature the constraint equations forbid a complete conversion to a single ground state, a thin layer that allows it must violate the dominant energy condition, and in the planar limit an extended front must leave an inward residual whose arrival at the centre gives a singularity unless a further mechanism acts; rotation is not covered (Sec. 9.11). A conjectured “mass limit followed by explosion” is not supported.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24370528
Primary Topic
Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Mass Scales of Singularity Resolution: Repulsion, Vacuum Cores and Observational Bounds in Regular Black-Hole Interiors

文正 陈
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
preprint

Mass Scales of Singularity Resolution: Repulsion, Vacuum Cores and Observational Bounds in Regular Black-Hole Interiors

文正 陈
preprint en

Abstract

If matter is not annihilated at a black-hole singularity, something must resist gravitational collapse. We ask what a repulsion built from only three ingredients—the mass M, Newton’s constant G and the mean inter-particle spacing d—can and cannot do, and what current observations allow. Our results are as follows. (i) Gravity per nucleon (10−15–10−11 N) lies 16–20 orders of magnitude below the QCD force scale (1.4 × 105 N); “comparable” holds only for the net force at equilibrium, and the Newtonian comparison fails above 8.3 M⊙. At a horizon, the force needed to hold a nucleon equals the QCD scale at a proper distance ℓc = 1.04 fm for every mass. (ii) Any positive-pressure repulsion obeys Mmax = 0.0851 c 3d 3/2/(G3/2m1/2) (4.07 M⊙ for nuclear onset) and cannot stop collapse beyond it; a bounce requires ρc2 + 3p < 0. (iii) A vacuum-like (p = −ρc2 ) core of density ρG gives horizons only for M ≳ 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ); the existence of 5 M⊙ horizons requires ρG ≳ 5 × 1018 kg m−3 , which is 49 times the hadron-fit QCD bag constant but only 1–13 times other estimates of the QCD vacuum energy. A closed cloud bounces at a = l, at a radius not exceeding (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 (and at most l for release at R0 ≥ Rs): there is no upper mass limit, only a threshold above which the bounce is guaranteed to be hidden. (iv) Quasinormal-mode shifts scale as ≈ 0.08 (l/M) 2 and are not yet constrained by GW250114 (δf220 = 0.02 ± 0.02). (v) A mass-dependent closure l = Rs needs a saturation density falling as M−2 , down to 10−2 kg m−3 for 3.6×1010 M⊙, and therefore cannot be an equation of state. (vi) Any horizonless static object whose energy density never falls below ρG has M < 0.173 c 3/(G3/2ρ 1/2 G ) whatever its pressures, and a thin-shell vacuum-core object obeying the dominant energy condition cannot lie closer than 1.04 Rs (surface redshift ≲ 4). (vii) In QCD-related matter (glueball and gluon gases, flux-tube networks, domain-wall lattices, bag-type vacuum) ρc2 + 3p < 0 needs matter more dilute than the vacuum energy, which compression moves away from. (viii) In an effective loop-quantum-gravity description positive-pressure matter does bounce at ρ ≈ 0.4ρPl, which removes the compression obstacle but makes every exterior signal smaller than 10−80; the bounce time is estimated to grow with mass, so there is no maximum mass. If the bounce time is 4k m2 tP , COBE/FIRAS limits bouncing primordial black holes near M∗ ∼ 1023 kg to f ≲ 4×10−8 of the dark matter and closes the asteroid-mass window; the limit depends on the energy partition and is conditional on the lifetime law (Sec. 9.4). (ix) A homogeneous ground-state core would hold only the fraction (ρ0/ρG) 1/2 of M at the bounce if its boundary were a timelike worldline, and no timelike interface can bounce hidden or hold M > Mcrit, whereas a spacelike transition at RG = (Rsl 2 ) 1/3 conserves the Misner–Sharp mass exactly (Sec. 9.9); the postulated equation of state P = −ρ 2/ρG has c 2 s < 0, and for a Planckian ρG the critical mass is of order the Planck mass (Sec. 9.8). (x) About 91–95% of a nucleon’s mass is QCD field and confinement energy, only ∼ 1% is the bare quark masses (Sec. 4.4). (xi) These conclusions are for a homogeneous, spherical, non-rotating cloud. For an inhomogeneous one the transition front is tilted: with continuous extrinsic curvature the constraint equations forbid a complete conversion to a single ground state, a thin layer that allows it must violate the dominant energy condition, and in the planar limit an extended front must leave an inward residual whose arrival at the centre gives a singularity unless a further mechanism acts; rotation is not covered (Sec. 9.11). A conjectured “mass limit followed by explosion” is not supported.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon