Development and contextual validation of justification-based assessment: An assessment design to elicit prospective teachers’ critical reasoning
Justification Based Assessment (JBA) is a formative assessment technique that involves students evaluating a true/false statement and providing a written argument to support the judgment. This article presents the development and contextual validation of JBA as the main practice of Pair A in the Improved Formative Assessment Practices (IFAPs) model for a group of prospective teachers who are taking Research Methods in Education (RME) course in an Arts and Science degree program at a public-sector university in Punjab, Pakistan. A pool of 85 items, related to 7 course topics, was prepared, then examined by a three-member expert panel (research, assessment, and English-language expertise) for content validity, relevance, and contextual feasibility, following a design and development approach. A total of 15 items were removed leaving 70 items for the final set items (10 items per topic). Mean expert ratings were 0.76 (CVI), 0.75 (relevance), and 0.75 (contextual feasibility); these values are interpreted in the context of the conventional content-validity benchmarks and the limitations of a three-expert review are discussed. The model of JBA was not used alone, but was integrated with four practice IFAPs model. The article provides a documented, context-specific method to develop a true/false format to a dialogic, reasoning-eliciting format for a formative task and to place the task in parallel with peer assessment. It is not tested here whether JBA increases engagement or critical thinking, which is the focus of the main intervention in the doctoral thesis.
Authors
- Saima Ahsan
Institutions
- University of Education (PK)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Perspectives in Social Sciences
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.63468/pss.211
- Primary Topic
- Student Assessment and Feedback
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00