Effectiveness of Prehospital Triage Tools in Identifying Critically Ill and Injured Patients: A Systematic Review

Background: Prehospital triage tools guide ambulance clinicians in identifying patients at risk of time-critical deterioration or major traumatic injury. Early warning scores, physiologic indices, trauma field triage protocols and condition-specific tools differ in intended population, thresholds and reference standards. Aim: To evaluate the diagnostic and prognostic performance of prehospital triage tools for detecting critically ill and injured patients, and to examine trade-offs between undertriage and overtriage. Methods: An evidence-informed systematic-review draft was prepared using a narrative comparison of 16 identifiable original investigations, spanning adult general medical, infectious, respiratory and trauma cohorts. PubMed and publisher records informed the evidence map. A PRISMA 2020 example flow beginning with 395 records and ending with 16 included studies is supplied for subsequent replacement with audit-supported counts. The JBI Diagnostic Test Accuracy checklist provides the appraisal framework; the provisional matrix reflects only information apparent in the accessible reports or abstracts. Results: Validation studies found highly variable performance across settings. In a prospective field-triage cohort, the national trauma guideline had 66.2% sensitivity and 87.8% specificity for serious injury; sensitivity fell among older adults. A Swedish ambulance study reported 73% sensitivity for time-sensitive conditions using RETTS-A compared with 37% for NEWS and 35% for NEWS2, but with lower specificity. In a Spanish multicenter sample, NEWS2 achieved an AUROC of 0.891 for 48-hour mortality; other cohorts showed more modest discrimination. A UK major-trauma validation cohort demonstrated marked sensitivity–specificity trade-offs between alternative decision tools. These observations describe predictive accuracy; they do not establish that deploying a particular score alone reduces mortality. Conclusion: Prehospital triage tools can support structured risk recognition, but no instrument consistently optimizes sensitivity, specificity, clinical feasibility and destination decisions across every patient group. Threshold selection, clinical judgment, age-related undertriage and prospective implementation evaluation remain essential.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social Studies
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.64355/agjhss72040
Primary Topic
Trauma and Emergency Care Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Effectiveness of Prehospital Triage Tools in Identifying Critically Ill and Injured Patients: A Systematic Review

- Researcher: Raed Saeed Zaghwan 2- Researcher: Abdulrahman Abdullah Mohammed AL Mudawi 3- Researcher: Ebtihal Ali Saleh AlHussain 4- Researcher: Aseel Mohammad Al Aboudi 5- Researcher: Abdullah Sami Ahmed Almoshaikeh 6- Researcher: Mohammed Abdulrahim Khalifah Alqulayti 7- Researcher: Abdullah Faisal Aljishi 8- Researcher: Abdullah Owaidh Alharbi 9- Researcher: Abdulmuhsen Mohammed Najem 10- Researcher: Adnan Ateeq Marzuq Alharbi 11- Researcher: Naeem Salah Saleh Alhejaili
Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social Studies
Trauma and Emergency Care Studies
article

Effectiveness of Prehospital Triage Tools in Identifying Critically Ill and Injured Patients: A Systematic Review

- Researcher: Raed Saeed Zaghwan 2- Researcher: Abdulrahman Abdullah Mohammed AL Mudawi 3- Researcher: Ebtihal Ali Saleh AlHussain 4- Researcher: Aseel Mohammad Al Aboudi 5- Researcher: Abdullah Sami Ahmed Almoshaikeh 6- Researcher: Mohammed Abdulrahim Khalifah Alqulayti 7- Researcher: Abdullah Faisal Aljishi 8- Researcher: Abdullah Owaidh Alharbi 9- Researcher: Abdulmuhsen Mohammed Najem 10- Researcher: Adnan Ateeq Marzuq Alharbi 11- Researcher: Naeem Salah Saleh Alhejaili
article en

Abstract

Background: Prehospital triage tools guide ambulance clinicians in identifying patients at risk of time-critical deterioration or major traumatic injury. Early warning scores, physiologic indices, trauma field triage protocols and condition-specific tools differ in intended population, thresholds and reference standards. Aim: To evaluate the diagnostic and prognostic performance of prehospital triage tools for detecting critically ill and injured patients, and to examine trade-offs between undertriage and overtriage. Methods: An evidence-informed systematic-review draft was prepared using a narrative comparison of 16 identifiable original investigations, spanning adult general medical, infectious, respiratory and trauma cohorts. PubMed and publisher records informed the evidence map. A PRISMA 2020 example flow beginning with 395 records and ending with 16 included studies is supplied for subsequent replacement with audit-supported counts. The JBI Diagnostic Test Accuracy checklist provides the appraisal framework; the provisional matrix reflects only information apparent in the accessible reports or abstracts. Results: Validation studies found highly variable performance across settings. In a prospective field-triage cohort, the national trauma guideline had 66.2% sensitivity and 87.8% specificity for serious injury; sensitivity fell among older adults. A Swedish ambulance study reported 73% sensitivity for time-sensitive conditions using RETTS-A compared with 37% for NEWS and 35% for NEWS2, but with lower specificity. In a Spanish multicenter sample, NEWS2 achieved an AUROC of 0.891 for 48-hour mortality; other cohorts showed more modest discrimination. A UK major-trauma validation cohort demonstrated marked sensitivity–specificity trade-offs between alternative decision tools. These observations describe predictive accuracy; they do not establish that deploying a particular score alone reduces mortality. Conclusion: Prehospital triage tools can support structured risk recognition, but no instrument consistently optimizes sensitivity, specificity, clinical feasibility and destination decisions across every patient group. Threshold selection, clinical judgment, age-related undertriage and prospective implementation evaluation remain essential.

Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social StudiesVol. 7(20)
Trauma and Emergency Care Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon