The Kirk Axial Pinch Theory of disk-galaxy rotation: fits and physical tests on 175 SPARC galaxies

This work has been submitted to the IEEE for possible publication. Copyright may be transferred without notice, after which this version may no longer be accessible. Version 3.1: theory renamed Kirk Axial Pinch Theory; results unchanged from v3 final. All computations are complete (1,225 nested-sampling and MCMC runs, 10 repeats of 10-fold cross-validation, sensitivity refits, 2000 bootstrap resamples). Summary: This paper tests the Kirk Axial Pinch Theory of disk-galaxy rotation: a current along each galaxy's axis with a Bennett-pinch radial profile (Bennett 1934), whose magnetic force is added to gravity. The added term is V_EM^2 = K r^2/(r^2 + rc^2), with two parameters per galaxy. It is fitted to all 175 SPARC rotation curves (3,391 points) with the same data, likelihood, nuisance treatment and optimisation as a Burkert halo, an NFW halo and the radial acceleration relation (RAR). With distance, inclination and mass-to-light ratios fixed (configuration F), the median reduced chi-squared is 0.706 [0.481, 0.909] for the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term, 0.710 [0.563, 0.941] for Burkert, 1.284 [1.013, 1.944] for NFW and 10.46 [7.48, 13.13] for the RAR with fixed acceleration scale (95% bootstrap intervals, 2000 resamples). With published priors on distance, inclination and mass-to-light ratios (configuration P; Li et al. 2018), the medians are 0.523 [0.379, 0.661], 0.533 [0.421, 0.706], 1.002 [0.834, 1.354] and 1.56 [1.21, 1.84]; the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term has the lower chi-squared than Burkert in 107 of 175 galaxies. Nested-sampling evidence summed over 175 galaxies gives ln Z(KAP) - ln Z(model) = 483 against Burkert and 957 against NFW; the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term has the higher evidence in 139 and 106 galaxies. The velocity term is identical to that of a cored logarithmic potential. A force derived radially from the Bennett current density gives median reduced chi-squared 1.84 [1.35, 2.63] (gas coupling) and 1.46 [1.10, 2.22] (all-baryon coupling). With an assumed current path length of 1 kpc (not measured), the median implied current is 4.5e+18 A; the median field at 10 kpc is 15.4 microgauss. In 25 of 26 comparisons with published field-strength estimates for SPARC galaxies, the implied field is more than twice the measured value. Predicting the model parameters from luminosity, disk scale length, surface brightness and H I mass gives held-out median reduced chi-squared 1.08 [0.84, 1.46] for the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term and 1.09 [0.90, 1.46] for Burkert (configuration P; 10 x 10-fold cross-validation). The two parameters are fitted for each galaxy. Code and per-galaxy results are included (code: MIT license; paper: CC BY 4.0). Changes in version 3:- Published nuisance priors (Gaussian distance and inclination, log-normal mass-to-light ratios, 0.1 dex; Li et al. 2018) added as configuration P alongside the fixed configuration F.- Least-squares fits repeated with 50 or more starting points per galaxy and model.- New models: RAR with free acceleration scale; Bennett current-density force with gas coupling and with all-baryon coupling (E3g, E3b); self-consistent mass-proportional term (SC); pseudo-isothermal halo (ISO).- Reduced chi-squared, AIC and BIC per galaxy and summed; 95% bootstrap intervals (2000 resamples) on sample statistics.- Nested-sampling evidence (dynesty) and MCMC posteriors (emcee) for each model and galaxy.- Cross-validated prediction of model parameters from galaxy properties, 10 x 10-fold.- Physical tests: implied current, field, magnetic vs midplane pressure, field energy, charge and electric field, vertical structure with published scale heights.- Implied field strengths compared with 26 published measurements for SPARC galaxies, with instrument, observing dates and source; field geometry compared with published pitch angles and rotation-measure patterns.- Comparison with the 3C 303 current measurement corrected to the published values (Kronberg et al. 2011).- Bibliography verified against Crossref, arXiv and ADS article scans.- PROBES held-out test: not computed (the PROBES release does not include gas profiles, H I masses or [3.6] photometry on the SPARC system).- Sensitivity of configuration P to the error floor (0 and 2 km/s) and prior widths (0.2 dex mass-to-light, doubled distance and inclination errors).- Acknowledgments: Yim et al. (2014) first author corrected to Kijeong Yim. The underlying ideas and data are those of earlier authors: the Bennett pinch (Bennett 1934); field-aligned currents (Birkeland 1908); cosmic plasma currents and circuits (Alfvén 1981, 1986); galactic-scale current-filament simulations and the 1/r filament force (Peratt & Green 1983; Peratt 1986); magnetic contributions to rotation curves (Nelson 1988; Battaner, Garrido, Membrado & Florido 1992; Battaner & Florido 1995; Ruiz-Granados, Rubiño-Martín, Florido, Battaner and Calvo 2010, 2012; Tsiklauri 2011); an MHD residual analysis of SPARC (Holmes 2026); and the SPARC rotation curves and mass models (Lelli, McGaugh & Schombert 2016), whose original H I and H-alpha rotation-curve sources are listed in SPARC Table 1. This paper does not claim priority for those ideas or data. Its contribution is a uniform two-parameter Kirk Axial Pinch fit to all 175 SPARC galaxies and a same-procedure comparison with Burkert, NFW and RAR models, with physical and observational tests. Published critiques of magnetic support for rotation curves are discussed in the paper. An AI assistant (Grok Bot) helped write the analysis code and draft the text. The author directed the work, checked the results, and takes full responsibility for the content.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24357643
Primary Topic
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Kirk Axial Pinch Theory of disk-galaxy rotation: fits and physical tests on 175 SPARC galaxies

Kirk Bagger
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
preprint

The Kirk Axial Pinch Theory of disk-galaxy rotation: fits and physical tests on 175 SPARC galaxies

Kirk Bagger
preprint en

Abstract

This work has been submitted to the IEEE for possible publication. Copyright may be transferred without notice, after which this version may no longer be accessible. Version 3.1: theory renamed Kirk Axial Pinch Theory; results unchanged from v3 final. All computations are complete (1,225 nested-sampling and MCMC runs, 10 repeats of 10-fold cross-validation, sensitivity refits, 2000 bootstrap resamples). Summary: This paper tests the Kirk Axial Pinch Theory of disk-galaxy rotation: a current along each galaxy's axis with a Bennett-pinch radial profile (Bennett 1934), whose magnetic force is added to gravity. The added term is V_EM^2 = K r^2/(r^2 + rc^2), with two parameters per galaxy. It is fitted to all 175 SPARC rotation curves (3,391 points) with the same data, likelihood, nuisance treatment and optimisation as a Burkert halo, an NFW halo and the radial acceleration relation (RAR). With distance, inclination and mass-to-light ratios fixed (configuration F), the median reduced chi-squared is 0.706 [0.481, 0.909] for the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term, 0.710 [0.563, 0.941] for Burkert, 1.284 [1.013, 1.944] for NFW and 10.46 [7.48, 13.13] for the RAR with fixed acceleration scale (95% bootstrap intervals, 2000 resamples). With published priors on distance, inclination and mass-to-light ratios (configuration P; Li et al. 2018), the medians are 0.523 [0.379, 0.661], 0.533 [0.421, 0.706], 1.002 [0.834, 1.354] and 1.56 [1.21, 1.84]; the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term has the lower chi-squared than Burkert in 107 of 175 galaxies. Nested-sampling evidence summed over 175 galaxies gives ln Z(KAP) - ln Z(model) = 483 against Burkert and 957 against NFW; the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term has the higher evidence in 139 and 106 galaxies. The velocity term is identical to that of a cored logarithmic potential. A force derived radially from the Bennett current density gives median reduced chi-squared 1.84 [1.35, 2.63] (gas coupling) and 1.46 [1.10, 2.22] (all-baryon coupling). With an assumed current path length of 1 kpc (not measured), the median implied current is 4.5e+18 A; the median field at 10 kpc is 15.4 microgauss. In 25 of 26 comparisons with published field-strength estimates for SPARC galaxies, the implied field is more than twice the measured value. Predicting the model parameters from luminosity, disk scale length, surface brightness and H I mass gives held-out median reduced chi-squared 1.08 [0.84, 1.46] for the Kirk Axial Pinch (KAP) term and 1.09 [0.90, 1.46] for Burkert (configuration P; 10 x 10-fold cross-validation). The two parameters are fitted for each galaxy. Code and per-galaxy results are included (code: MIT license; paper: CC BY 4.0). Changes in version 3:- Published nuisance priors (Gaussian distance and inclination, log-normal mass-to-light ratios, 0.1 dex; Li et al. 2018) added as configuration P alongside the fixed configuration F.- Least-squares fits repeated with 50 or more starting points per galaxy and model.- New models: RAR with free acceleration scale; Bennett current-density force with gas coupling and with all-baryon coupling (E3g, E3b); self-consistent mass-proportional term (SC); pseudo-isothermal halo (ISO).- Reduced chi-squared, AIC and BIC per galaxy and summed; 95% bootstrap intervals (2000 resamples) on sample statistics.- Nested-sampling evidence (dynesty) and MCMC posteriors (emcee) for each model and galaxy.- Cross-validated prediction of model parameters from galaxy properties, 10 x 10-fold.- Physical tests: implied current, field, magnetic vs midplane pressure, field energy, charge and electric field, vertical structure with published scale heights.- Implied field strengths compared with 26 published measurements for SPARC galaxies, with instrument, observing dates and source; field geometry compared with published pitch angles and rotation-measure patterns.- Comparison with the 3C 303 current measurement corrected to the published values (Kronberg et al. 2011).- Bibliography verified against Crossref, arXiv and ADS article scans.- PROBES held-out test: not computed (the PROBES release does not include gas profiles, H I masses or [3.6] photometry on the SPARC system).- Sensitivity of configuration P to the error floor (0 and 2 km/s) and prior widths (0.2 dex mass-to-light, doubled distance and inclination errors).- Acknowledgments: Yim et al. (2014) first author corrected to Kijeong Yim. The underlying ideas and data are those of earlier authors: the Bennett pinch (Bennett 1934); field-aligned currents (Birkeland 1908); cosmic plasma currents and circuits (Alfvén 1981, 1986); galactic-scale current-filament simulations and the 1/r filament force (Peratt & Green 1983; Peratt 1986); magnetic contributions to rotation curves (Nelson 1988; Battaner, Garrido, Membrado & Florido 1992; Battaner & Florido 1995; Ruiz-Granados, Rubiño-Martín, Florido, Battaner and Calvo 2010, 2012; Tsiklauri 2011); an MHD residual analysis of SPARC (Holmes 2026); and the SPARC rotation curves and mass models (Lelli, McGaugh & Schombert 2016), whose original H I and H-alpha rotation-curve sources are listed in SPARC Table 1. This paper does not claim priority for those ideas or data. Its contribution is a uniform two-parameter Kirk Axial Pinch fit to all 175 SPARC galaxies and a same-procedure comparison with Burkert, NFW and RAR models, with physical and observational tests. Published critiques of magnetic support for rotation curves are discussed in the paper. An AI assistant (Grok Bot) helped write the analysis code and draft the text. The author directed the work, checked the results, and takes full responsibility for the content.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon