Institutional Logic and Organizational Mechanisms in the Convergence of Sustainability Disclosure Standards: A Prospective Analysis of A+H-Share Listed Companies
Convergence of sustainability disclosure standards has become a central issue in accounting research, yet existing studies compare mainly the text of standards and pay limited attention to how firms generate and integrate the information they disclose. Drawing on institutional theory, this paper conducts a prospective rather than an empirical analysis. It decomposes China's Basic Standard for Enterprise Sustainability Disclosure and its climate-related standard, together with IFRS S1/S2, along six dimensions—objective and primary users, materiality boundary, the four core elements, financial effects and the value chain, connectivity of information, and implementation and assurance—and then identifies the coercive, mimetic and normative pressures facing A+H-share listed companies and asks which departments receive them inside the organization. A typology of four execution modes is constructed along two continua, the integration of governance responsibility and the integration of data standards, and is illustrated with three anonymized firm contexts. The paper argues that the two frameworks are structurally compatible and differ mainly in objective functions and materiality boundaries, while the depth of quantification, the value-chain boundary, Scope 3 treatment and assurance remain the practical gaps. Its central claim is that differences in standards are exogenous conditions, and whether they become differences in disclosure depends on how the organization processes information: compliance, finance, strategy and sustainability functions receive different pressures and bring logics that coexist in one report without being reconciled. Four testable propositions follow, together with a layered convergence path that treats financial materiality as the baseline layer, impact materiality as a supplementary layer, and mutual recognition of equivalence as the institutional safeguard. As a conceptual study, the paper does not sample firms or conduct statistical tests.
Authors
- 马波
Publication Details
- Journal
- Asia Pacific Economic and Management Review
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.62177/apemr.v3i6.1832
- Primary Topic
- Corporate Social Responsibility Reporting
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00