Ressentiment, the Government of Precarity, and Collective Complicity in Lars von Trier's Dogville
This essay examines how Lars von Trier’s Dogville transforms resentment, insecurity, and the language of communal morality into an apparatus of coercion. Drawing on Nietzsche’s analysis of ressentiment, it argues that Grace is repeatedly made culpable regardless of her conduct, while Vera’s jealousy and Tom Edison’s self-protective philosophical discourse displace responsibility onto the persecuted stranger. Sartrean bad faith illuminates Tom’s transformation from moral educator into an informant. Judith Butler’s analysis of unequal exposure to harm and Isabell Lorey’s work on precarization clarify how the town actively produces Grace’s inability to refuse the conditions imposed upon her. The heavy chained wheel gives this political mechanism its grotesquely material form, turning ostensibly reciprocal labor into immobilization and servitude. The children’s bell makes public the sexual violence that the community privately tolerates and knowingly permits. The concluding discussion interprets the bell as an acoustic supplement to Dogville’s wall-less theatrical architecture, where the Lacanian dynamic of extimacy exposes what communal life seeks to deny: private violation has already become common knowledge. The essay ultimately understands collective complicity not as a failure of information but as the routinization of injustice within recognizable ethical vocabularies. RÉSUMÉ Cet essai étudie la manière dont Dogville de Lars von Trier transforme le ressentiment, l’insécurité et le langage moral de la communauté en un dispositif de coercition. À partir de l’analyse nietzschéenne du ressentiment, il montre que Grace est continuellement rendue coupable, indépendamment de sa conduite, tandis que la jalousie de Vera et le discours philosophique d’autolégitimation de Tom Edison font peser la responsabilité sur l’étrangère persécutée. La mauvaise foi sartrienne éclaire le passage de Tom de la posture d’éducateur moral à celle de délateur. Les travaux de Judith Butler sur l’exposition inégalement répartie à la violence et ceux d’Isabell Lorey sur la précarisation permettent de comprendre comment la ville fabrique l’impossibilité, pour Grace, de refuser les conditions qui lui sont imposées. La lourde roue attachée à une chaîne donne une forme matérielle grotesque à ce mécanisme, transformant un travail prétendument réciproque en immobilisation et en servitude. La cloche actionnée par les enfants rend publiquement audible la violence sexuelle que la communauté tolère en privé. Envisagée comme un supplément acoustique à l’architecture théâtrale sans murs de Dogville, elle manifeste la dynamique d’extimité : la violation réputée privée relève déjà d’un savoir collectif. La complicité communautaire apparaît donc moins comme un manque d’information que comme la banalisation de l’injustice au sein de vocabulaires éthiques familiers. SCHOLARLY SERIES AND RELATED PUBLICATION Collection: Notebook · Notes on the Question of Evil Document: Document 03 — The Obscene Covenant of Community Film: Lars von Trier, Dogville (2003) Entry: 04 of 09 Article: The Wheel and the Bell: Ressentiment, the Government of Precarity, and Collective Complicity in Lars von Trier’s Dogville Author: Salah el Moncef Affiliation: Nantes Université, France ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-9305-3043 Original online essay: https://www.salahelmoncef.com/notebook/question-of-evil/dogville-the-wheel-and-the-bell/ Complete nine-entry collection: https://www.salahelmoncef.com/notebook/question-of-evil/dogville/ Author website: https://www.salahelmoncef.com/ Institutional profile: https://www.univ-nantes.fr/salah-el-moncef-bin-khalifa Independent scholarly archival edition of the complete illustrated essay. The PDF preserves the opening analysis of Nietzschean ressentiment; “Guilt without an offense”; “The philosopher who becomes an informant”; “Precarity made into government”; “The weight of the exception”; “The bell that announces what everyone knows”; the three original interpretive illustrations and captions; and the complete six-entry Works cited. English and French abstracts and subject keywords have been added. The discussion of extimacy and the bell is preserved in full.
Authors
- el Moncef (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-9305-3043)
Institutions
- Nantes Université (FR)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377540
- Primary Topic
- Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00