Sustaining population health initiatives: how Australian policymakers and practitioners respond to real-world challenges, a qualitative study

Background Sustaining prevention initiatives in real-world settings is complex, requiring planned, feasible responses to challenges to enable long-term delivery. In this study we centered the perspectives of those navigating challenges and supporting sustainment at the systems level – policymakers (decision makers in government agencies) and practitioners (implementation decision makers). The study aims were to (1) explore how Australian policymakers and practitioners view sustainment of chronic disease prevention initiatives and (2a) assess the challenges they experience when sustaining chronic disease prevention initiatives, and (2b) how they respond to these challenges. Methods We employed a pragmatic exploratory qualitative approach. We purposefully sampled policymakers to ensure participation across all Australian jurisdictions (states and territories) and then used snowball sampling to identify practitioners. Data were collected in one-on-one online interviews or small group interviews, following a semi-structured discussion guide. Transcripts were analysed in Nvivo using Framework Analysis, inductively coding content with the research objectives and collaboratively developing final themes. As a final step, themes for challenges were mapped to the themes for responses used to address them. Results We interviewed 35 participants encompassing every state and territory of Australia. Aim (1): Policymakers and practitioners conceptualised sustainment across multiple outcomes including initiative and behaviour maintenance and the need to benefit populations. Aim (2a): Challenges to sustaining initiatives included: funding and resource constraints , political landscape (e.g., shifting agenda), demonstrating impact (e.g., insufficient data systems), and implementation context constraints (e.g., staff turnover). Aim (2b): Policymakers and practitioners employed a range of strategies to respond to sustainment challenges including: adapt (e.g., less intensive delivery strategies), harness implementing context (e.g, embedding in existing systems), evaluate and monitor (e.g., data reporting systems), navigate the decision point (e.g., innovative funding options), and early intentional efforts (e.g., planning). When responses were mapped to challenges, we found most targeted funding challenges, fewest addressed demonstrating impact challenges. Conclusion Our findings highlight how policymakers and practitioners navigate challenges to sustaining initiatives with real-world responses. Future research is needed to categorise and test policy sustainment strategies used in practice. Such evidence can support decision-making and guide resource allocation to improve prevention initiative sustainment.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11134099/v1
Primary Topic
Health Policy Implementation Science
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Sustaining population health initiatives: how Australian policymakers and practitioners respond to real-world challenges, a qualitative study

Luke Wolfenden, Rachel Sutherland, Cassandra Lane, Belinda Peden et al.
Research Square
Health Policy Implementation Science
preprint

Sustaining population health initiatives: how Australian policymakers and practitioners respond to real-world challenges, a qualitative study

Luke Wolfenden, Rachel Sutherland, Cassandra Lane, Belinda Peden, Carly Gardner, Alix Hall, Nicole Nathan, Will Pascoe
preprint en

Abstract

Background Sustaining prevention initiatives in real-world settings is complex, requiring planned, feasible responses to challenges to enable long-term delivery. In this study we centered the perspectives of those navigating challenges and supporting sustainment at the systems level – policymakers (decision makers in government agencies) and practitioners (implementation decision makers). The study aims were to (1) explore how Australian policymakers and practitioners view sustainment of chronic disease prevention initiatives and (2a) assess the challenges they experience when sustaining chronic disease prevention initiatives, and (2b) how they respond to these challenges. Methods We employed a pragmatic exploratory qualitative approach. We purposefully sampled policymakers to ensure participation across all Australian jurisdictions (states and territories) and then used snowball sampling to identify practitioners. Data were collected in one-on-one online interviews or small group interviews, following a semi-structured discussion guide. Transcripts were analysed in Nvivo using Framework Analysis, inductively coding content with the research objectives and collaboratively developing final themes. As a final step, themes for challenges were mapped to the themes for responses used to address them. Results We interviewed 35 participants encompassing every state and territory of Australia. Aim (1): Policymakers and practitioners conceptualised sustainment across multiple outcomes including initiative and behaviour maintenance and the need to benefit populations. Aim (2a): Challenges to sustaining initiatives included: funding and resource constraints , political landscape (e.g., shifting agenda), demonstrating impact (e.g., insufficient data systems), and implementation context constraints (e.g., staff turnover). Aim (2b): Policymakers and practitioners employed a range of strategies to respond to sustainment challenges including: adapt (e.g., less intensive delivery strategies), harness implementing context (e.g, embedding in existing systems), evaluate and monitor (e.g., data reporting systems), navigate the decision point (e.g., innovative funding options), and early intentional efforts (e.g., planning). When responses were mapped to challenges, we found most targeted funding challenges, fewest addressed demonstrating impact challenges. Conclusion Our findings highlight how policymakers and practitioners navigate challenges to sustaining initiatives with real-world responses. Future research is needed to categorise and test policy sustainment strategies used in practice. Such evidence can support decision-making and guide resource allocation to improve prevention initiative sustainment.

Research Square
Health Policy Implementation Science
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon