From Novel Combinations to Informative Absence: Structural permission, communicative opportunity, and form choice in language learning
Language learners must infer both which novel expressions are grammatically licensed and when an expression's continued absence becomes evidence against it. We develop a generative theory uniting these capacities through counterfactual expression opportunities, decomposing utterance generation into structural permission, communicative opportunity, and form choice. First, we show that shared predictive continuations enable learners to infer structural permission for unseen word–construction pairings across thirty artificial grammars (mean AUC 0.945 after 120 sentences). Second, to explain how learners interpret subsequent omissions under hierarchical uncertainty, we derive a joint evidence law governed by context diversity and within-context repetition, alongside an exact finite-sample context-refinement inequality. This generative coupling yields two key predictions: positive observations of related expressions calibrate expected usage to sharpen subsequent negative evidence, and candidates with stronger initial permission can undergo steeper posterior declines when accompanied by higher expected use (reversing their initial ordering after six omissions in a fixed-rate example). Third, we prove that whereas raw occurrence counts confound semantic availability with form selection, scene-level opportunity observations identify both factors. Empirically, reanalyzing artificial-language experiments with adults and children shows meaning-conditioned restriction and finds that judgments of restricted combinations improve predictions of held-out production across 399 participants (+0.036 nats per production). Furthermore, naturalistic child-directed and child speech across eleven families and six corpora exhibits pervasive source-level usage clustering beyond lexical, number, and dependency-role controls, empirically grounding hierarchical rate uncertainty. Finally, cross-linguistic modeling of causative judgments across five languages demonstrates that structural compatibility and calibrated usage probabilities draw on distinct distributional, semantic, and discriminative cues. Together, these findings establish how the organization and calibration of communicative opportunities govern the evidential value of linguistic absence.
Authors
- Yanzhe Zhao (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6997-9841)
Institutions
- Tianjin University (CN)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24360441
- Primary Topic
- Language Development and Disorders
- Type
- preprint