The owl is a contradiction: severe mismatch between owl diversity, research effort and conservation needs

Owls are the least-studied group of raptors, yet more than half of the 242 recognised species have declining populations and over a quarter are globally threatened or Near Threatened. Whether this knowledge deficit reflects ecological constraints, geographic bias, or species level traits remains untested. Here, we present the first global, species-level assessment of field-based research effort across all owl species, and identify the factors that determine which species are studied and which are ignored. We systematically reviewed owl-related publications indexed on the Web of Science, using transformer-based document embeddings (SPECTER) and unsupervised clustering for initial thematic filtering, then manually screened all 2,952 retained articles to assign focal species and classify records into 18 research themes, yielding 3,268 species-level records. We modelled research effort as a function of geographic, ecological, and taxonomic predictors using spatial and phylogenetic generalised least squares. Nearly 45% of owl species had no indexed field study, rising to 58% among threatened species. Research effort was profoundly unequal: the 10 most studied species, all from temperate realms and nine of them of Least Concern, comprised over two thirds of the corpus. Spatial models outperformed phylogenetic models, indicating that research bias is structured geographically, not evolutionarily. Biogeographic realm was the dominant predictor: Nearctic species received 21 times more research attention than Afrotropical species, and a single Nearctic species (Spotted Owl; Strix occidentalis) accumulated more records than all species in the four tropical realms combined. Species with broader latitudinal ranges received more attention, whereas IUCN threat status did not predict research effort, indicating that conservation urgency does not get translated into scientific attention. Thematic composition varied across realms with natural history and conservation themes were underrepresented in tropical regions. Natural history themes have declined globally since the 1980s. Taxonomy accounted for only 1% of the corpus. These biases are not innocuous, we identified a shortfall cascade, in which gaps in one knowledge domain propagated into others: unresolved taxonomy obscures species boundaries; without acoustic data, species cannot be detected in the field; without detection, population data cannot be generated; and without population data, conservation assessments rely on indirect proxies rather than direct evidence. The ultimate consequence is that species may go extinct before being described, or disappear unnoticed within polytypic complexes. In owls, which are nocturnal, cryptic, and dependent on acoustic communication, bioacoustics is a foundational subject, yet behaviour and bioacoustics represented <8% of all records. We provide region-specific research priorities for the four tropical realms, where 84.6% of owl species occur but only 11.7% of research effort is directed. Breaking this cascade requires a reorientation of scientific incentives: taxonomic and natural history contributions must be valued; acoustic data must be treated as priority; and the global south must become a locus of scientific leadership, rather than a site of data extraction. Otherwise, we will continue to document extinctions after the fact or not notice them at all. We predict that similar shortfalls occur in other nocturnal, cryptic taxa, such members of Caprimulgiformes (nightjars, potoos, etc.) and forest-dwelling nocturnal mammals.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
EcoEvoRxiv
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.32942/x26116
Primary Topic
Avian ecology and behavior
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The owl is a contradiction: severe mismatch between owl diversity, research effort and conservation needs

Judit K. Szabo, Luis Peixoto
EcoEvoRxiv
Avian ecology and behavior
preprint

The owl is a contradiction: severe mismatch between owl diversity, research effort and conservation needs

Judit K. Szabo, Luis Peixoto
preprint en

Abstract

Owls are the least-studied group of raptors, yet more than half of the 242 recognised species have declining populations and over a quarter are globally threatened or Near Threatened. Whether this knowledge deficit reflects ecological constraints, geographic bias, or species level traits remains untested. Here, we present the first global, species-level assessment of field-based research effort across all owl species, and identify the factors that determine which species are studied and which are ignored. We systematically reviewed owl-related publications indexed on the Web of Science, using transformer-based document embeddings (SPECTER) and unsupervised clustering for initial thematic filtering, then manually screened all 2,952 retained articles to assign focal species and classify records into 18 research themes, yielding 3,268 species-level records. We modelled research effort as a function of geographic, ecological, and taxonomic predictors using spatial and phylogenetic generalised least squares. Nearly 45% of owl species had no indexed field study, rising to 58% among threatened species. Research effort was profoundly unequal: the 10 most studied species, all from temperate realms and nine of them of Least Concern, comprised over two thirds of the corpus. Spatial models outperformed phylogenetic models, indicating that research bias is structured geographically, not evolutionarily. Biogeographic realm was the dominant predictor: Nearctic species received 21 times more research attention than Afrotropical species, and a single Nearctic species (Spotted Owl; Strix occidentalis) accumulated more records than all species in the four tropical realms combined. Species with broader latitudinal ranges received more attention, whereas IUCN threat status did not predict research effort, indicating that conservation urgency does not get translated into scientific attention. Thematic composition varied across realms with natural history and conservation themes were underrepresented in tropical regions. Natural history themes have declined globally since the 1980s. Taxonomy accounted for only 1% of the corpus. These biases are not innocuous, we identified a shortfall cascade, in which gaps in one knowledge domain propagated into others: unresolved taxonomy obscures species boundaries; without acoustic data, species cannot be detected in the field; without detection, population data cannot be generated; and without population data, conservation assessments rely on indirect proxies rather than direct evidence. The ultimate consequence is that species may go extinct before being described, or disappear unnoticed within polytypic complexes. In owls, which are nocturnal, cryptic, and dependent on acoustic communication, bioacoustics is a foundational subject, yet behaviour and bioacoustics represented <8% of all records. We provide region-specific research priorities for the four tropical realms, where 84.6% of owl species occur but only 11.7% of research effort is directed. Breaking this cascade requires a reorientation of scientific incentives: taxonomic and natural history contributions must be valued; acoustic data must be treated as priority; and the global south must become a locus of scientific leadership, rather than a site of data extraction. Otherwise, we will continue to document extinctions after the fact or not notice them at all. We predict that similar shortfalls occur in other nocturnal, cryptic taxa, such members of Caprimulgiformes (nightjars, potoos, etc.) and forest-dwelling nocturnal mammals.

EcoEvoRxiv
Avian ecology and behavior
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon