Adaptive Mutual-Human Reasoning: A Unified Framework for Multi-Model Collaborative Reasoning and Human-Assisted Reasoning Through Adaptive Selection, Switching, and Integration
Large language models (LLMs) have increasingly demonstrated the ability to perform complex reasoning through interaction with other models, while human reasoning continues to provide essential capabilities involving contextual understanding, domain expertise, critical judgment, conceptual interpretation, and responsibility. Existing research has explored chain-of-thought reasoning, self-reflection, multi-agent debate, collaborative reasoning, human-in-the-loop systems, and human–AI interaction. However, many existing approaches primarily emphasize improving reasoning within a particular operational paradigm, combining human feedback with automated reasoning, or introducing human intervention into an otherwise established multi-agent process. A broader architectural question remains: should a reasoning task always be performed through collaboration among multiple AI models, or should it sometimes be transferred to human-assisted reasoning, with the system adaptively determining which mechanism is appropriate at each stage? This paper introduces Adaptive Mutual-Human Reasoning (AMHR), a general framework derived from the Universal Mutual-Human Model (UMHM), which establishes a unified architecture for adaptive reasoning through two distinct but combinable dimensions: Mutual Reasoning and Human-Assisted Reasoning. Mutual Reasoning involves two or more distinct AI models exchanging reasoning paths, generating alternative hypotheses, challenging intermediate conclusions, identifying logical inconsistencies, and collaboratively constructing solutions. Human-Assisted Reasoning involves human individuals or groups contributing reasoning, contextual knowledge, conceptual interpretation, critical judgment, or directional guidance to the reasoning process. Rather than permanently assigning reasoning to either mechanism, AMHR introduces Adaptive Reasoning Mechanism Selection, Adaptive Reasoning Mechanism Switching, Adaptive Reasoning Combination, and Adaptive Reasoning Reconfiguration. The framework enables a reasoning system to begin with multi-model collaboration, introduce human assistance when necessary, prioritize human reasoning when appropriate, or return to multi-model collaboration when human intervention is no longer required. A formal configuration space, adaptive decision model, transition policy, reasoning lifecycle, architectural layers, theoretical propositions, evaluation methodology, and governance principles are developed. The framework additionally distinguishes between reasoning quality, reasoning confidence, model agreement, evidence sufficiency, uncertainty, human expertise, and transition costs, avoiding the assumption that either model consensus or human judgment is inherently correct. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to formally articulate, within the UMHM theoretical foundation, a function-general adaptive reasoning architecture specifically integrating multi-model collaborative reasoning and human-assisted reasoning through explicit mechanism selection, bidirectional switching, combination, and structural reconfiguration. This contribution concerns the proposed unified adaptive architecture rather than the invention of multi-agent reasoning or human-in-the-loop reasoning individually. The framework provides a theoretical foundation for intelligent reasoning systems that can dynamically reorganize the relationship between artificial and human reasoning according to task requirements, uncertainty, capabilities, resources, and accountability.
Authors
- Jincheng Zhang (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-1860-0009)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24361924
- Primary Topic
- Logic, Reasoning, and Knowledge
- Type
- preprint