MOTOR COMPETENCE ASSESSMENT IN TALENT IDENTIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT: A THEORETICAL AND COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF BOT-2 AND BOT-3

Background. Talent identification and development have become central research themes in contemporary sport science, sport psychology and physical education. The increasing competitiveness of elite sport systems has intensified the need for valid and reliable predictors of future athletic success. Traditional approaches relying on early competitive success or anthropometric criteria have beencriticized for limited predictive validity and for promoting premature sport specialization. Consequently, recent research emphasizes multidimensional and longitudinal models that integrate motor, psychological, biological and environmental factors. Within these frameworks, general motor competence has gained prominence as a key developmental construct.Objectives. This methodological approach aligns with conceptual and theoretical articles commonly published in sports science and sports psychology journals and aims to provide an overview of the variables involved in the sports selection – early talent identification and predictability of sports performance relationship.Methods. The present study adopts a qualitative and theoretical research design based on comparative document analysis and integrative literature review. Primary sources include the official manuals of BOT-2 and BOT-3, which were examined with regard to test structure, assessed motor domains, scoring procedures and age norms.Results. Both BOT-2 and BOT-3 assess core dimensions of motor competence, including fine motor precision, manual coordination, balance and strength-related abilities. BOT-2 has been widely applied in educational and clinical contexts. However, studies involving athletic populations have reported ceiling effects and reduced score variability among highly skilled youth. BOT-3 introduces extended age norms up to 25 years, additional composite scores and an advanced balance subtest. These features address limitations identified in earlier research and enhance the test’s sensitivity for higher levels of motor proficiency, as highlighted in recent methodological adaptations for young athletes. Conclusion. This extended theoretical analysis highlights the relevance of standardized motor competence assessment in contemporary talent identification frameworks. BOT-3 offers improved methodological sensitivity and broader applicability compared with BOT-2, making it particularly suitable for adolescent and young adult athletic populations. Future research should prioritizelongitudinal validation studies and the integration of motor competence assessment with other performance-relevant domains in evidence-based selection systems.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
University Arena.
Published
2026-11-17
Primary Topic
Children's Physical and Motor Development
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

MOTOR COMPETENCE ASSESSMENT IN TALENT IDENTIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT: A THEORETICAL AND COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF BOT-2 AND BOT-3

Bogdan Gozu, Cătălin Șerban, Alina-Mihaela Stoica
University Arena.
Children's Physical and Motor Development
article

MOTOR COMPETENCE ASSESSMENT IN TALENT IDENTIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT: A THEORETICAL AND COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF BOT-2 AND BOT-3

Bogdan Gozu, Cătălin Șerban, Alina-Mihaela Stoica
article en

Abstract

Background. Talent identification and development have become central research themes in contemporary sport science, sport psychology and physical education. The increasing competitiveness of elite sport systems has intensified the need for valid and reliable predictors of future athletic success. Traditional approaches relying on early competitive success or anthropometric criteria have beencriticized for limited predictive validity and for promoting premature sport specialization. Consequently, recent research emphasizes multidimensional and longitudinal models that integrate motor, psychological, biological and environmental factors. Within these frameworks, general motor competence has gained prominence as a key developmental construct.Objectives. This methodological approach aligns with conceptual and theoretical articles commonly published in sports science and sports psychology journals and aims to provide an overview of the variables involved in the sports selection – early talent identification and predictability of sports performance relationship.Methods. The present study adopts a qualitative and theoretical research design based on comparative document analysis and integrative literature review. Primary sources include the official manuals of BOT-2 and BOT-3, which were examined with regard to test structure, assessed motor domains, scoring procedures and age norms.Results. Both BOT-2 and BOT-3 assess core dimensions of motor competence, including fine motor precision, manual coordination, balance and strength-related abilities. BOT-2 has been widely applied in educational and clinical contexts. However, studies involving athletic populations have reported ceiling effects and reduced score variability among highly skilled youth. BOT-3 introduces extended age norms up to 25 years, additional composite scores and an advanced balance subtest. These features address limitations identified in earlier research and enhance the test’s sensitivity for higher levels of motor proficiency, as highlighted in recent methodological adaptations for young athletes. Conclusion. This extended theoretical analysis highlights the relevance of standardized motor competence assessment in contemporary talent identification frameworks. BOT-3 offers improved methodological sensitivity and broader applicability compared with BOT-2, making it particularly suitable for adolescent and young adult athletic populations. Future research should prioritizelongitudinal validation studies and the integration of motor competence assessment with other performance-relevant domains in evidence-based selection systems.

University Arena.
Children's Physical and Motor Development
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon