FANCESA: The Decision That Never Comes — Corporate Governance and Investment Decisions in a Bolivian Cement Company with Three Public Owners (Teaching Case, English and Spanish)
Teaching case. In March 2015, Fábrica Nacional de Cemento S.A. (FANCESA), of Sucre, was one of Bolivia's most profitable companies: Bs 805 million in sales, Bs 233 million in profit, a 17% return on equity and almost no debt. It needed a new production line of about USD 222 million to keep up with new competitors in Santa Cruz, its main market. The feasibility study was ready; what was missing was for its three public owners (the Government of Chuquisaca, the Municipality of Sucre and the Universidad San Francisco Xavier, each with about a third and none with a majority) to agree on where to build it. Between 2012 and 2016 the decision was postponed amid regional politics, constant management turnover and high dividend payouts, while competitors built close to the market. The plant was finally built in Sucre and began operating in 2021, into an oversupplied market; the company ended up renegotiating its bonds and posting losses. Central question: what is worth more, the right decision or a timely decision? The case covers corporate governance of state-owned companies with split ownership, location decisions with transport cost as the key variable, the opportunity cost of delay, dividend policy and bondholder protection. Includes discussion questions and a teaching note. Resumen (español): En marzo de 2015, FANCESA era una de las empresas más rentables de Bolivia y necesitaba una nueva línea de producción de unos USD 222 millones. Sus tres dueños públicos no se ponían de acuerdo en dónde construirla. La decisión se postergó hasta 2016, mientras la competencia construía cerca del mercado; la planta llegó tarde, a un mercado saturado, y la empresa terminó reestructurando sus bonos. El caso plantea qué vale más: la decisión correcta o la decisión a tiempo. Incluye preguntas de discusión y nota docente. Files: EN_FANCESA.pdf (English) and Caso_FANCESA.pdf (Spanish).
Authors
- Rodrigo Demian Regalsky Granier (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6723-3915)
Institutions
- Universidad Mayor de San Andrés (BO)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24352124
- Primary Topic
- Corporate Finance and Governance
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00