Expert surgeons’ conceptualisation of tissue tension management: a qualitative study across three surgical specialties

Background Controlling tissue tension is a fundamental intraoperative manoeuvre; however, much of the knowledge that guides it remains tacit, and no shared framework exists to describe how experts perceive and adjust it. Consequently, this skill is difficult to teach and assess; intraoperative teaching is often limited to fragmentary instructions, and assessment tools capture observable movements but not the cognition behind them. This study aimed to clarify how expert surgeons control tissue tension and to develop a cross-specialty conceptual framework to support teaching and assessment. Methods Board-certified surgeons who had performed at least 500 operations as the primary surgeon in head and neck surgery, gynaecological oncology, or gastrointestinal surgery were purposively recruited from multiple institutions in Japan. Three in-person focus groups, one per specialty, were conducted between May 2024 and September 2025, using countertraction as the starting point for discussion. Verbatim transcripts were analysed inductively using reflexive thematic analysis, both within and across specialties. Results Twenty-two surgeons participated (seven head and neck surgeons, seven gynaecological oncologists, and eight gastrointestinal surgeons), yielding 520 meaning units. Tension management emerged as a higher-order concept encompassing traction, retraction, triangulation, exposure, and collaboration with assistants. It comprises three layers: WHY (principles: safety, efficiency, and collaboration), HOW (judgement: situational reading and adaptive decision-making), and WHAT (execution: traction point, direction, and magnitude). Changes in the operative field and tissue responses after execution prompted a cyclical recalibration of judgement. The same structure was identified in all three specialty groups, with differences between specialties appearing mainly in the conditions interpreted through situational reading, such as anatomy, tissue characteristics, devices, and platforms. Conclusions Among expert surgeons, tissue tension management was organised as a WHY-HOW-WHAT cognitive–operative process that links principles, judgement, and execution. This framework provides a cross-specialty process language for tacit surgical skills and a conceptual basis for relating observable performance measures to the cognition behind them. Both applications require validation in educational settings and against intraoperative data.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11316616/v1
Primary Topic
Surgical Simulation and Training
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Expert surgeons’ conceptualisation of tissue tension management: a qualitative study across three surgical specialties

Takashi Mukaigawa, Shiori Aibara, Takeshi Kimura, Saseem Poudel et al.
1 links
Research Square
Surgical Simulation and Training
preprint

Expert surgeons’ conceptualisation of tissue tension management: a qualitative study across three surgical specialties

Takashi Mukaigawa, Shiori Aibara, Takeshi Kimura, Saseem Poudel, Naohito Hato, Kazuhisa Kitami, Hiroyuki Wakisaka, Takashi Kitani, Sohei Mitani, Yuki Irifune, Yuki Hosokawa, Kayo Sakamoto, Kohei Takagi
preprint en

Abstract

Background Controlling tissue tension is a fundamental intraoperative manoeuvre; however, much of the knowledge that guides it remains tacit, and no shared framework exists to describe how experts perceive and adjust it. Consequently, this skill is difficult to teach and assess; intraoperative teaching is often limited to fragmentary instructions, and assessment tools capture observable movements but not the cognition behind them. This study aimed to clarify how expert surgeons control tissue tension and to develop a cross-specialty conceptual framework to support teaching and assessment. Methods Board-certified surgeons who had performed at least 500 operations as the primary surgeon in head and neck surgery, gynaecological oncology, or gastrointestinal surgery were purposively recruited from multiple institutions in Japan. Three in-person focus groups, one per specialty, were conducted between May 2024 and September 2025, using countertraction as the starting point for discussion. Verbatim transcripts were analysed inductively using reflexive thematic analysis, both within and across specialties. Results Twenty-two surgeons participated (seven head and neck surgeons, seven gynaecological oncologists, and eight gastrointestinal surgeons), yielding 520 meaning units. Tension management emerged as a higher-order concept encompassing traction, retraction, triangulation, exposure, and collaboration with assistants. It comprises three layers: WHY (principles: safety, efficiency, and collaboration), HOW (judgement: situational reading and adaptive decision-making), and WHAT (execution: traction point, direction, and magnitude). Changes in the operative field and tissue responses after execution prompted a cyclical recalibration of judgement. The same structure was identified in all three specialty groups, with differences between specialties appearing mainly in the conditions interpreted through situational reading, such as anatomy, tissue characteristics, devices, and platforms. Conclusions Among expert surgeons, tissue tension management was organised as a WHY-HOW-WHAT cognitive–operative process that links principles, judgement, and execution. This framework provides a cross-specialty process language for tacit surgical skills and a conceptual basis for relating observable performance measures to the cognition behind them. Both applications require validation in educational settings and against intraoperative data.

Research Square
Hokkaido University (JP), Shizuoka Cancer Center (JP), Ehime Prefectural University of Health Science (JP), Aichi Cancer Center (JP), Ehime University (JP), Nagoya University (JP)
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science
Good health and well-being
Surgical Simulation and Training
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon