State-equivalent Gibbs mappings and heat-capacity ambiguity in open quantum systems
At finite system–environment coupling, an equilibrium reduced state need not be Gibbsian with respect to the bare system Hamiltonian, even though the same state admits an exact Gibbs representation generated by a generally temperature-dependent state-equivalent operator. These two statements are thermodynamically inequivalent. We first formulate this distinction for an arbitrary full-rank reduced state and show that the canonical response obtained by freezing its state-equivalent Gibbs generator is fixed entirely by the variance of the modular Hamiltonian. A finite zero-temperature value of this mapped response therefore measures residual modular fluctuations of a mixed reduced ground state rather than a thermodynamic heat capacity or a violation of the third law. We then specialize to a damped quantum harmonic oscillator, for which the modular response reduces exactly to a closed expression in terms of the Gaussian symplectic eigenvalue. In parallel, we distinguish this reduced-state quantity from the temperature derivative of the bare oscillator energy and from the reduced-partition-function/Hamiltonian-of-mean-force response relevant at finite coupling. Across sub-Ohmic, Ohmic, and super-Ohmic reservoirs, the bare-energy response vanishes algebraically at low temperature with an exponent fixed by the infrared bath spectrum, whereas the mapped residual is controlled by reduced-state mixedness and environmental dressing. The analysis clarifies what effective Gibbs descriptions can (and cannot) establish about thermodynamics of strongly coupled open quantum systems.
Authors
- Jishad Kumar (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4153-1495)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Physical review. E
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1103/b5lb-25rx
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00