The unbearable aesthetics of AI translation-hidden in plain sight: how a legal text interpellates even those it does not address
This article argues that legal texts interpellate even those they do not address – and that this interpellation, hidden in plain sight in the text’s surface forms, is precisely what AI-assisted translation cannot reproduce. Drawing on three legal translation encounters translated into Finnish by the author – a decision of the French Tribunal des conflits (C3841, 12 December 2011), an English First-Tier Tribunal property decision (Harris v Trigg [2018] UKFTT 323 (PC)), and a Dutch administrative court ruling (Rechtbank Rotterdam, ROT 25/4666, 6 January 2026) – the article develops a central argument: AI operates as a pure signifying chain without a subject; law operates through interpellation, requiring a subject who can reconstruct that hailing force across jurisdictions that may have no institutional home for it. Following Lacan and Žižek, the article argues that the legal symbolic order is hidden in plain sight – its interpellating mechanisms becoming visible only when translation forces contact with a different symbolic order. The AI that smooths over these gaps performs an ideological function, making the particular appear universal. The translator’s subject – hidden in plain sight in the translation he produces – is the living refutation of this smoothness.
Authors
- Jonathan Widell
Institutions
- McGill University (CA)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Philosophy of Translation
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1080/29984750.2026.2764630
- Primary Topic
- Translation Studies and Practices
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00