Consciousness Requires Mortality: Individuation and Irre- versible Risk as Joint Preconditions for Subjective Experience
The major theories of consciousness — Integrated Information Theory, Global WorkspaceTheory, the Free Energy Principle, and Higher-Order Thought theory — describe how con-scious systems are organised but not why that organisation is accompanied by experience.We call this the How/Why gap and argue that it cannot be closed at the level of mecha-nism: not theoretically, because no computational condition entails experience, and notempirically, because no recording method captures synaptic-scale events across a wholeliving brain. We instead advance a structural hypothesis about the physical precondi-tions under which subjective experience becomes functionally indispensable: individua-tion (the non-copyability of the system’s computational identity) and mortality (genuine,irreversible risk of permanent annihilation), jointly necessary. A 2×2 analysis illustratesthat the two conditions play distinct roles and that whenever either is absent, qualialose their functional role of signalling irreversible threat to an irreplaceable self. Thisdecomposes what the mortal-computation literature, Causal Liability Theory, Froese’s en-activism, and Seth’s biological naturalism each treat as a single property, and answerstwo questions Seth leaves open: which features of life matter for consciousness, andwhat a theory of substrate-dependent computation would look like. It yields architecturalconditions for artificial consciousness — hardware-bound computation, non-extractablestate, non-resettable learning, active self-maintenance, irreversible cessation — with afalsification condition and a prediction. Current AI, built on copyable parameters andrestorable state, fails both preconditions. A system satisfying them would be an artificialorganism, and building one carries the responsibility of creating something that can bepermanently lost.
Authors
- Franny Philos Sophia (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7089-5265)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24330488
- Primary Topic
- Philosophy and Theoretical Science
- Type
- preprint