Under-perception of overweight, not genetic risk, tracks weight-loss goal-setting in a direct-to-consumer genetics cohort

Services that rely on people to recognise their own weight and set their own goals may miss those who do not see themselves as overweight. We examined how adults perceive their weight, whether genetic risk of obesity, measured body size or early weight history explains who under-perceives it, and how perception relates to the weight-management goal they set, in a direct-to-consumer genetics cohort that includes people who have not sought care for their weight (FitnessGenes; N = 20,617). Although 61% of participants were overweight or obese by BMI, only 37% described themselves as such; among those overweight or obese by BMI, 64.0% placed themselves in a lighter category than their BMI indicated. Under-perception was more common in men than in women (73.5% vs 51.6%), in younger adults and at lower BMI, and a sex difference in the same direction, though smaller, was present when non-recognition of overweight was assessed against waist-to-height ratio rather than BMI. FTO rs9939609 behaved as an obesity risk variant (+0.46 kg/m2 BMI and OR 1.18 for recalled childhood obesity per risk allele) but did not predict under-perception at a given BMI (per-allele OR 0.97, 95% CI 0.92-1.03), and neither did MC4R rs17782313 nor a combined score. A recalled history of childhood obesity, by contrast, was associated with heavier self-perception at the same adult BMI (+10.0 percentage points). At the same BMI, participants who under-perceived their weight were about half as likely to set a weight-loss goal (26.8% vs 47.5%; OR 0.52, 95% CI 0.48-0.56); among those obese by BMI, 49% who recognised it chose weight loss, against 18% who did not. Genotype did not predict goal-setting beyond its effect on BMI. Men were less likely both to recognise overweight and, having recognised it, to choose weight loss. Genetic risk of obesity therefore identifies who is likely to be heavier but not who will recognise it, and self-perception marks a group, mainly men and those at lower BMI, whom self-directed weight-management services are likely to under-reach.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
medRxiv
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.11.16.26367268
Primary Topic
Eating Disorders and Behaviors
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Under-perception of overweight, not genetic risk, tracks weight-loss goal-setting in a direct-to-consumer genetics cohort

Nathan R. West, Stuart J. Grice, Olatz Mompeo-Masachs
medRxiv
Eating Disorders and Behaviors
preprint

Under-perception of overweight, not genetic risk, tracks weight-loss goal-setting in a direct-to-consumer genetics cohort

Nathan R. West, Stuart J. Grice, Olatz Mompeo-Masachs
preprint en

Abstract

Services that rely on people to recognise their own weight and set their own goals may miss those who do not see themselves as overweight. We examined how adults perceive their weight, whether genetic risk of obesity, measured body size or early weight history explains who under-perceives it, and how perception relates to the weight-management goal they set, in a direct-to-consumer genetics cohort that includes people who have not sought care for their weight (FitnessGenes; N = 20,617). Although 61% of participants were overweight or obese by BMI, only 37% described themselves as such; among those overweight or obese by BMI, 64.0% placed themselves in a lighter category than their BMI indicated. Under-perception was more common in men than in women (73.5% vs 51.6%), in younger adults and at lower BMI, and a sex difference in the same direction, though smaller, was present when non-recognition of overweight was assessed against waist-to-height ratio rather than BMI. FTO rs9939609 behaved as an obesity risk variant (+0.46 kg/m2 BMI and OR 1.18 for recalled childhood obesity per risk allele) but did not predict under-perception at a given BMI (per-allele OR 0.97, 95% CI 0.92-1.03), and neither did MC4R rs17782313 nor a combined score. A recalled history of childhood obesity, by contrast, was associated with heavier self-perception at the same adult BMI (+10.0 percentage points). At the same BMI, participants who under-perceived their weight were about half as likely to set a weight-loss goal (26.8% vs 47.5%; OR 0.52, 95% CI 0.48-0.56); among those obese by BMI, 49% who recognised it chose weight loss, against 18% who did not. Genotype did not predict goal-setting beyond its effect on BMI. Men were less likely both to recognise overweight and, having recognised it, to choose weight loss. Genetic risk of obesity therefore identifies who is likely to be heavier but not who will recognise it, and self-perception marks a group, mainly men and those at lower BMI, whom self-directed weight-management services are likely to under-reach.

medRxiv
Good health and well-being
Eating Disorders and Behaviors
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon