A Set-Theoretic Tuple Model with Level-Consistent Normalization and Non-Compensatory Aggregation for Assessing the Cyber Resilience of Critical Infrastructure

Cyber-resilience engineering frameworks organize protective activity into goals, objectives and basic actions but give no formal rules for turning heterogeneous security measurements into auditable scores. Building on earlier set-theoretic data and metric models of such a framework, this paper develops a set-theoretic tuple model for assessing the cyber resilience of critical infrastructure and analyzes, with proofs, the evaluation rules on which those models relied. The hierarchy of the Cyber Resiliency Engineering Framework is encoded as an indexed family of sets with an injective identifier map; admissible threat-scenario projections form a finite distributive lattice; and each basic action carries a tuple of metrics. A clipped affine normalization agrees with a five-level class table if and only if the gaps between class boundaries are proportional to those between score breakpoints, and the two-threshold rule of the earlier models is consistent with no table; an anchored piecewise-linear normalization is consistent by construction. A capped knockout operator, which keeps a missing critical capability from being offset by other metrics, retains veto, idempotency and continuity in the normalized scores, whereas neither the hard gate nor power discounting has all three. In an illustrative bank phishing scenario, 9 of 38 observed metrics receive a linear score outside their tabulated level, and the threat-intelligence action moves from high (0.903) to above average (0.856). A parameter study shows how the cap threshold, the weights and the choice of core metrics affect the verdicts. Constructed degraded states activate the cap, the operator is compared with the geometric and harmonic means and the minimum, and a randomized check of the formal rules over 100,000 synthetic states shows that the effects are not peculiar to the example; it does not validate the policy parameters. The model is a formal scoring method that turns heterogeneous security evidence into reproducible, auditable scores; its rules are mathematically valid, but it has not been validated against expert judgment or field data, and no operational or predictive validity under an adversary is claimed.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Information
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/info17111170
Primary Topic
Information and Cyber Security
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Set-Theoretic Tuple Model with Level-Consistent Normalization and Non-Compensatory Aggregation for Assessing the Cyber Resilience of Critical Infrastructure

Dmytro Prokopovych-Tkachenko, Олександр Григорович Корченко, Дмитро Свинаренко, Olga Torstensson et al.
2 links
Information
Information and Cyber Security
article

A Set-Theoretic Tuple Model with Level-Consistent Normalization and Non-Compensatory Aggregation for Assessing the Cyber Resilience of Critical Infrastructure

Dmytro Prokopovych-Tkachenko, Олександр Григорович Корченко, Дмитро Свинаренко, Olga Torstensson, Yuliia Khokhlachova
article en

Abstract

Cyber-resilience engineering frameworks organize protective activity into goals, objectives and basic actions but give no formal rules for turning heterogeneous security measurements into auditable scores. Building on earlier set-theoretic data and metric models of such a framework, this paper develops a set-theoretic tuple model for assessing the cyber resilience of critical infrastructure and analyzes, with proofs, the evaluation rules on which those models relied. The hierarchy of the Cyber Resiliency Engineering Framework is encoded as an indexed family of sets with an injective identifier map; admissible threat-scenario projections form a finite distributive lattice; and each basic action carries a tuple of metrics. A clipped affine normalization agrees with a five-level class table if and only if the gaps between class boundaries are proportional to those between score breakpoints, and the two-threshold rule of the earlier models is consistent with no table; an anchored piecewise-linear normalization is consistent by construction. A capped knockout operator, which keeps a missing critical capability from being offset by other metrics, retains veto, idempotency and continuity in the normalized scores, whereas neither the hard gate nor power discounting has all three. In an illustrative bank phishing scenario, 9 of 38 observed metrics receive a linear score outside their tabulated level, and the threat-intelligence action moves from high (0.903) to above average (0.856). A parameter study shows how the cap threshold, the weights and the choice of core metrics affect the verdicts. Constructed degraded states activate the cap, the operator is compared with the geometric and harmonic means and the minimum, and a randomized check of the formal rules over 100,000 synthetic states shows that the effects are not peculiar to the example; it does not validate the policy parameters. The model is a formal scoring method that turns heterogeneous security evidence into reproducible, auditable scores; its rules are mathematically valid, but it has not been validated against expert judgment or field data, and no operational or predictive validity under an adversary is claimed.

InformationVol. 17(11)
State University of Trade and Economics (UA), State University of Information and Communication Technologies (UA), University of Customs and Finance (UA), State Scientific Institution "Institute of Information, Security and Law of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine" (UA), Halmstad University (SE)
Information and Cyber Security
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon