Seeded infinite models of the Austin identities E5093 and E5107

Version 2. Kisielewicz showed that every finite magma satisfying x = y◇(y◇(y◇(x◇(z◇y)))) (E5093) has at most one element and asked whether the identity has a nontrivial model. A countably infinite model was first announced by vkg on the Lean Zulip in August 2026. We give an independent construction on the natural numbers by completing finite partial tables, and the same argument applies to the companion identity x = y◇(y◇(y◇(z◇(x◇y)))) (E5107). The construction accepts a prescribed finite seed: every admissible finite table extends to a model on the natural numbers that keeps its entries. A single seed with twelve entries thereby refutes five implications from the public SAIR research collections: E5093 ⇒ E10218, E5107 ⇒ E5012, E40951 ⇒ E40070, E40951 ⇒ E4916 and E5107 ⇒ E22818. The premises have only trivial finite models, so finite search cannot refute these implications. All proofs have been checked in Lean 4. Changes from version 1: version 1 described the E5093 question as open; it was first answered by vkg (Lean Zulip, #Equational, topic "A countably infinite model of Equation 5093", 5 August 2026). Version 2 credits that result, adds the companion identity E5107, the seeded completion theorem, and the five SAIR countermodels. Files: the paper (PDF and LaTeX source); E5093.lean, Replay.lean and lean-toolchain (the E5093 model from the empty table, Lean 4.24.0, Std only); SAIR-five-countermodels.zip (Seeded5093.lean, Seeded5107.lean, SAIRCountermodels.lean, ReplayAll.lean, the Python check check_diagram.py, and five standalone certificates for the SAIR stage-2 checker). Axioms reported for all main theorems: propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound. The five certificates were accepted by a local run of the official checker; this is not a recorded online submission.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24340685
Primary Topic
Advanced Algebra and Logic
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Seeded infinite models of the Austin identities E5093 and E5107

Jason Peng
3 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Advanced Algebra and Logic
preprint

Seeded infinite models of the Austin identities E5093 and E5107

Jason Peng
preprint en

Abstract

Version 2. Kisielewicz showed that every finite magma satisfying x = y◇(y◇(y◇(x◇(z◇y)))) (E5093) has at most one element and asked whether the identity has a nontrivial model. A countably infinite model was first announced by vkg on the Lean Zulip in August 2026. We give an independent construction on the natural numbers by completing finite partial tables, and the same argument applies to the companion identity x = y◇(y◇(y◇(z◇(x◇y)))) (E5107). The construction accepts a prescribed finite seed: every admissible finite table extends to a model on the natural numbers that keeps its entries. A single seed with twelve entries thereby refutes five implications from the public SAIR research collections: E5093 ⇒ E10218, E5107 ⇒ E5012, E40951 ⇒ E40070, E40951 ⇒ E4916 and E5107 ⇒ E22818. The premises have only trivial finite models, so finite search cannot refute these implications. All proofs have been checked in Lean 4. Changes from version 1: version 1 described the E5093 question as open; it was first answered by vkg (Lean Zulip, #Equational, topic "A countably infinite model of Equation 5093", 5 August 2026). Version 2 credits that result, adds the companion identity E5107, the seeded completion theorem, and the five SAIR countermodels. Files: the paper (PDF and LaTeX source); E5093.lean, Replay.lean and lean-toolchain (the E5093 model from the empty table, Lean 4.24.0, Std only); SAIR-five-countermodels.zip (Seeded5093.lean, Seeded5107.lean, SAIRCountermodels.lean, ReplayAll.lean, the Python check check_diagram.py, and five standalone certificates for the SAIR stage-2 checker). Axioms reported for all main theorems: propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound. The five certificates were accepted by a local run of the official checker; this is not a recorded online submission.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Advanced Algebra and Logic
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon