A general unit-invariance theorem for the bean relation: Toward structurally invariant expressions for magnetization-derived critical current density of rectangular parallelepiped samples in perpendicular field

The determination of the critical current density Jc from magnetization hysteresis measurements in superconductors is routinely performed using analytical expressions derived from the Bean critical state model. For rectangular parallelepiped samples in a perpendicular magnetic field, two numerical prefactors, 2 and 20, are commonly reported in the literature. These formulations are often regarded as equivalent representations differing only by unit conventions. However, while the prefactor 2 is universally treated as dimensionless, the prefactor 20 is considered implicitly dimensional or sometimes appears with explicit dimensions. In this paper, we examine the presence of dimensions in this prefactor and discuss the implications associated with the use of the corresponding expression. By proving that only structurally invariant formulations remain unchanged under arbitrary coherent transformations of units, this work provides a rigorous criterion to distinguish universal geometrical expressions from convention-dependent ones. In particular, we establish a general unit-invariance theorem and demonstrate that the prefactor 2, which emerges uniquely from geometrical integration of the critical current distribution, is invariant under arbitrary coherent transformations of units. By contrast, the prefactor 20 which tacitly implies the dimensions [A cm2/emu], and arises within a hybrid CGS electromagnetic framework through the incorporation of specific electromagnetic conversion factors into the geometrical relation, is not invariant under unit transformations. The present discussion addresses invariance at the level of physical quantities, rather than mere numerical equivalence within fixed conventions. Our analysis illustrates how retaining the prefactor 20 outside its native unit framework may introduce systematic numerical deviations when the units of the physical quantities are modified without explicit re-derivation of the coefficient. These deviations do not reflect limitations of the critical state model itself, but rather the convention-dependent nature of hybrid prefactors. We emphasize that calculating the correct value is not a matter of choosing a particular electromagnetic unit system. However, expressions that embed conversion factors within numerical coefficients are inherently unit-dependent and may reduce transparency. For methodological robustness, reproducibility, and reliable comparison of data obtained by different groups and experimental systems, the structurally invariant formulation of the Bean relation provides a more transparent representation and may therefore be preferred when reporting magnetization-derived critical current densities.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Superconductor Science and Technology
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6668/aec3da
Primary Topic
Physics of Superconductivity and Magnetism
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A general unit-invariance theorem for the bean relation: Toward structurally invariant expressions for magnetization-derived critical current density of rectangular parallelepiped samples in perpendicular field

Armando Galluzzi, M. Polichetti
2 links
Superconductor Science and Technology
Physics of Superconductivity and Magnetism
article

A general unit-invariance theorem for the bean relation: Toward structurally invariant expressions for magnetization-derived critical current density of rectangular parallelepiped samples in perpendicular field

Armando Galluzzi, M. Polichetti
article en

Abstract

The determination of the critical current density Jc from magnetization hysteresis measurements in superconductors is routinely performed using analytical expressions derived from the Bean critical state model. For rectangular parallelepiped samples in a perpendicular magnetic field, two numerical prefactors, 2 and 20, are commonly reported in the literature. These formulations are often regarded as equivalent representations differing only by unit conventions. However, while the prefactor 2 is universally treated as dimensionless, the prefactor 20 is considered implicitly dimensional or sometimes appears with explicit dimensions. In this paper, we examine the presence of dimensions in this prefactor and discuss the implications associated with the use of the corresponding expression. By proving that only structurally invariant formulations remain unchanged under arbitrary coherent transformations of units, this work provides a rigorous criterion to distinguish universal geometrical expressions from convention-dependent ones. In particular, we establish a general unit-invariance theorem and demonstrate that the prefactor 2, which emerges uniquely from geometrical integration of the critical current distribution, is invariant under arbitrary coherent transformations of units. By contrast, the prefactor 20 which tacitly implies the dimensions [A cm2/emu], and arises within a hybrid CGS electromagnetic framework through the incorporation of specific electromagnetic conversion factors into the geometrical relation, is not invariant under unit transformations. The present discussion addresses invariance at the level of physical quantities, rather than mere numerical equivalence within fixed conventions. Our analysis illustrates how retaining the prefactor 20 outside its native unit framework may introduce systematic numerical deviations when the units of the physical quantities are modified without explicit re-derivation of the coefficient. These deviations do not reflect limitations of the critical state model itself, but rather the convention-dependent nature of hybrid prefactors. We emphasize that calculating the correct value is not a matter of choosing a particular electromagnetic unit system. However, expressions that embed conversion factors within numerical coefficients are inherently unit-dependent and may reduce transparency. For methodological robustness, reproducibility, and reliable comparison of data obtained by different groups and experimental systems, the structurally invariant formulation of the Bean relation provides a more transparent representation and may therefore be preferred when reporting magnetization-derived critical current densities.

Superconductor Science and Technology
University of Salerno (IT)
Physics of Superconductivity and Magnetism
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon