Building Relational Trust with Students Experiencing Prenatal and Acute Trauma: Revisiting a Qualitative Action Research Study Through the 5Rs Relational Framework™
Students whose development has been shaped by prenatal trauma and later acute trauma often arrive at school with stress-response systems tuned for survival. Their behavior is frequently read as defiance, and schools respond with exclusion, which deepens mistrust and repeats the cycle. This working paper revisits the author's earlier qualitative action research study of relational trust-building practices in a high-poverty public secondary school serving grades 7–12. Over a 12-week intervention, adults used consistent mentorship, restorative conversations, predictable accountability structures, and trauma-responsive classroom routines. Thematic analysis of student interviews, educator focus groups, reflective journals, and discipline and attendance records produced four themes: experiencing relational safety, accountability without exclusion, increased academic engagement, and shifts in school climate with reductions in violence and suspension. Negative cases showed that trust stabilized behavior rather than eliminating it. The paper then reads these findings through the 5Rs Relational Framework™ (Relational, Real, Relevant, Rigorous, Results), first introduced in the author's book 240 Ways to Close the Achievement Gap: Teachers Only! (2010), showing how each principle maps to what students and educators described and translating the results into practice guidance for school and district leaders. The central argument is that sustainable reductions in school violence and suspension come from trust-informed accountability, not intensified control.
Authors
- MDonnell Tenner
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24342816
- Primary Topic
- Education Discipline and Inequality
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00