SAE Propagation of Cultivation Paper 5: The Propagation of Cultivation: Leading / SAE 涵育的传播 Paper 5: 涵育的传播:引领
Paper 1 said that three things pass through a person, and that one of them, a way of standing, cannot be taught but can be seen. This paper reads the side that is seen: leading. Leading is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees. Having activities of one's own is not in itself leading. Leading lets someone know that the position exists; it does not produce 15DD. At the earlier person's end there are three things: giving conditions, being seen, and collision in actual dealings. They are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter; the later person's step remains his own. Leading is not registered, not assessed, not inspected. When a practice is fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content that can be followed. When a person deliberately makes public how he judges and how he answers disagreement, whether there is leading in it still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw. What is seen includes how one turns back after falling back. What is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied: the later person need not treat people the way the earlier one did. Through a book or a screen a way of standing may also be seen: in how the author treats the reader here and now, in an act that has itself been left behind, and by way of an account of an actual encounter; an account has to be checked for its grounds. That a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward that reader at the time. The paper refers back to Xiao Hong's passage on Lu Xun used in the previous paper, and to Rilke's letters as read in Cultivation Theory. It does not show that a person who has seen will come to stand there, gives no method for leading, does not rate what anyone has lived out, and certifies no one's layer. 第一篇说,经过一个人的有三样,其中站法教不了,但能被看见。这一篇读被看见的那一面:引领。引领是一个人在自己的生活与来往里活出承认、被另一个人看见的那一面;有自己的活动,不直接就是引领。 引领让人知道那个位置在;它不生出 15DD。前一个人这一端有三样:给条件,被看见,实际来往里的碰撞。三样分开读,不预定由同一个人在同一次来往里齐备;后一个人的那一步仍是他自己的。引领不登记,不考核,不验收。把一套做法定成对方照做的样板,传下去的是可以照做的内容;一个人有意把自己怎样判断、怎样回应不同意公开出来,其中有没有引领,仍看实际的作用与对方看见了什么。被看见的也包括回落以后怎样回头。 由具体的做法看见的,是一种不必照搬的站法:后一个人待人不必像前一个人。隔着书与屏幕,也可能看见一种站法:在作者当下怎样待读者里,在留下来的作为本身里,也可以经由对一次实际来往的记述;记述要核它的根据。后来的读者看见了,不倒推作者当时朝这位读者做了什么。 这一篇回指前一篇萧红写鲁迅的那一段,并回指涵育论读过的里尔克的信。它不证明看见了的人就会站过去,不给怎样引领的办法,不评谁活出了什么,也不认证谁在哪一层。
Authors
- Han Qin (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-9583-0018)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351777
- Primary Topic
- Education, Philosophy, and Society
- Type
- preprint