Close the operation, not the line: a closure savings formula for maintaining a cryptographic-inventory scanner
For seven weeks, the fix list of the open-source post-quantum readiness scanner qrp-mcp kept growing. Its items were found in public discussions and in our own probes, many of them probes we ran deliberately to find gaps, and the rate did not fall. We drew the fix list (438 items, 1 October – 17 November 2026) as a network. Linked by shared tags, the items form dense communities: Louvain modularity is 0.56, against 0.22 for the same network rewired with node degrees kept. Relabelled by cryptographic operation and ecosystem, they fall into 121 families. Our first explanation, that families keep growing for weeks, did not survive a shuffled-date control: 31% of detection rows join their (operation, ecosystem) family more than a week after its first row, against 46% with shuffled dates. Gaps arrive in batches when we run a probe. We model maintenance as reports that each reveal one spelling of an operation, and give the expected number of gaps under three policies: fixing the reported line, closing the operation's documented spellings at its first report (reactive), and closing them from the documentation before any report (proactive). The first and last are classical occupancy expectations; the reactive term is the part we derive. Two consequences follow: if spellings are static and fixes permanent, closure never yields more gaps than line fixing, on every sequence of reports, not only in expectation; and the price of waiting for the first report, reactive against proactive, is at most one expected gap per family. We describe changes to qrp-mcp, built on a development branch and not yet released: a catalogue of documented spellings per (operation, ecosystem) kept as tests, and an output section that states which pairs are closed against their catalogue. A maintainer loop re-reads the documentation and proposes new spellings, which enter the scanner only with a source and a test.
Authors
- Stanimir Tenev (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-0106-863X)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24336931
- Primary Topic
- Software Engineering Research
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00