Beyond gravity and density: Proposing “Semantic arguability” as a third dimension of knowledge-building in long-form interviews about AI

This study proposes and tests an additional dimension for the semantic plane of Legitimation Code Theory (LCT). Because the plane, formed by semantic gravity and semantic density, does not register whether a proposition is offered in a form that a hearer can answer, Semantic Arguability is proposed as an optional third dimension, defined as the degree to which a practice places its propositions within reach of contestation and realised through Engagement, Reification and Rhetorical Scaffolding. The dimension is tested on a corpus of 39 long-form interviews about artificial intelligence (AI) (542,863 tokens), all transcribed from YouTube captions, with the individual interview as the unit of analysis. Arguability, indexed by the proportion of uncertainty markers realised nominally (the reification ratio), varies widely between interviews (.000–.667). It is not associated with the gravity proxy (ρ = .03), its association with the density proxy is modest and not significant (ρ = .30), and interviews that lie close together on the plane can differ in arguability by as much as .528. Its association with governance lexis (ρ = .38) depends largely on the noun risk and is treated as suggestive. Key semantic domain analysis shows that capability, change and success are more strongly over-represented than their negations, while the vocabulary of doubt and worry is also over-represented. Arguability did not differ across professional roles. The findings suggest that the plane, as operationalised here, does not recover arguability, although with a sample of this size only moderate or strong associations can be detected.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Social Sciences & Humanities Open
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2026.104085
Primary Topic
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Beyond gravity and density: Proposing “Semantic arguability” as a third dimension of knowledge-building in long-form interviews about AI

朱文忠, Congcong Wang
1 links
Social Sciences & Humanities Open
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
article

Beyond gravity and density: Proposing “Semantic arguability” as a third dimension of knowledge-building in long-form interviews about AI

朱文忠, Congcong Wang
article en

Abstract

This study proposes and tests an additional dimension for the semantic plane of Legitimation Code Theory (LCT). Because the plane, formed by semantic gravity and semantic density, does not register whether a proposition is offered in a form that a hearer can answer, Semantic Arguability is proposed as an optional third dimension, defined as the degree to which a practice places its propositions within reach of contestation and realised through Engagement, Reification and Rhetorical Scaffolding. The dimension is tested on a corpus of 39 long-form interviews about artificial intelligence (AI) (542,863 tokens), all transcribed from YouTube captions, with the individual interview as the unit of analysis. Arguability, indexed by the proportion of uncertainty markers realised nominally (the reification ratio), varies widely between interviews (.000–.667). It is not associated with the gravity proxy (ρ = .03), its association with the density proxy is modest and not significant (ρ = .30), and interviews that lie close together on the plane can differ in arguability by as much as .528. Its association with governance lexis (ρ = .38) depends largely on the noun risk and is treated as suggestive. Key semantic domain analysis shows that capability, change and success are more strongly over-represented than their negations, while the vocabulary of doubt and worry is also over-represented. Arguability did not differ across professional roles. The findings suggest that the plane, as operationalised here, does not recover arguability, although with a sample of this size only moderate or strong associations can be detected.

Social Sciences & Humanities OpenVol. 14
Guangdong University of Foreign Studies (CN), Huanghuai University (CN)
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon