Age assessment in migrant children: scientific uncertainty, clinical ethics, and migration policy—the Italian perspective
Italy provides an informative case study combining a substantial population of unaccompanied migrant children with an established legal and procedural framework for their protection.No currently available method can determine chronological age with sufficient precision to support individual legal classification, particularly around the age of 18 (2,3). Age assessment should therefore be understood as an estimation process, not a definitive diagnostic procedure.Radiological techniques assess skeletal maturation as a proxy for chronological age and are subject to substantial biological and methodological variability (2,3).Accordingly, wrist radiography should not be used as a standalone method for legal age determination (2)(3)(4).Where radiological assessment is undertaken, its findings should be interpreted within a multidisciplinary assessment that integrates clinical, developmental, psychological, and social information, while explicitly recognizing the limitations and residual uncertainty of age estimation (3,4).The scientific limitations of age assessment also raise important concerns under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, particularly with regard to procedural safeguards and child protection standards, including the principle of the benefit of the doubt when uncertainty about age remains (5).Errors in age determination may have profound consequences. A child incorrectly classified as an adult may lose access to child-specific protection measures and, depending on the applicable legal framework and individual circumstances, may instead enter adult migration, reception, or removal procedures, potentially including, in some circumstances, immigration detention in facilities such as repatriation centers (Centri di permanenza per il rimpatrio, CPR).Immigration detention is associated with adverse physical and mental health consequences, with children and adolescents being particularly vulnerable to its harmful effects (6)(7)(8).Law No. 47/2017 (the "Zampa Law") strengthened the protection framework for unaccompanied foreign minors in Italy and introduced Article 19-bis into Legislative Decree No. 142/2015, establishing specific safeguards for their identification and age assessment (9). Where well-founded doubts remain concerning the declared age, the law provides for a socio-medical assessment within a specific procedural framework, including judicial oversight and safeguards for the individual concerned.The State-Regions Agreement of 9 July 2020 (10) adopted the Multidisciplinary Protocol for Age Assessment of Unaccompanied Foreign Minors. Under the ordinary procedure, assessment follows a sequential and multidisciplinary approach, integrating a social interview, a psychological or neuropsychiatric assessment, and a paediatric auxological examination. The assessment must be conducted by appropriately trained professionals, with the involvement of a cultural mediator and using the least invasive methods possible. Under the subsequent amendments to Article 19-bis, the socio-medical assessment must be concluded within 60 days of the order authorizing it (11).The legal framework was subsequently amended by Decree-Law No. 133 of 5 October 2023, converted, with amendments, into Law No. 176 of 1 December 2023. In particular, Article 5, paragraph 1, letter b), point 3, introduced paragraph 6-ter into Article 19-bis, providing for a specific procedure in cases involving substantial, multiple, and closely spaced arrivals. In such circumstances, the public security authority may order anthropometric measurements or other medical examinations, including radiological examinations, subject to the statutory safeguards and authorization of the competent public prosecutor. This exceptional procedure should be distinguished from the ordinary multidisciplinary assessment (11).Accordingly, wrist radiography is not established as a universally mandatory, standalone method for determining chronological age. Although radiological examinations may be used in specific circumstances provided for by law, their findings must be interpreted in light of the scientific limitations of skeletal maturation as a proxy for chronological age. This distinction is particularly important because legal and administrative systems require decisions concerning minority status, whereas scientific methods can only provide estimates subject to residual uncertainty.Despite the existence of a national legal and procedural framework, implementation of ageassessment procedures may vary across Italian regions and local services. A national mapping exercise documented differences in identification and age-assessment practices, as well as challenges relating to linguistic and cultural mediation and the conditions under which children are interviewed (12). Reported challenges included heterogeneous availability of cultural mediators, variable access to multidisciplinary teams, and differences in referral pathways and interview conditions across regions. These organizational difficulties highlight the importance of effective coordination between healthcare providers, social services, and judicial authorities. They also underline the need for systematic monitoring of age-assessment practices, including the number and types of assessments performed and the use of radiological examinations, to better evaluate implementation across the country.Ethical tensions are particularly evident in clinical practice when administrative authorities request a rapid or definitive age classification on the basis of medical examinations that cannot establish chronological age with certainty. For example, a pediatrician or radiologist may be asked to perform a wrist radiograph to resolve doubts about whether an unaccompanied adolescent is below or above the legal threshold of 18 years. However, skeletal maturation varies between individuals, and its timing may be influenced by sex, nutritional status, illness, and individual developmental differences (2,4).A radiographic finding therefore cannot, on its own, establish chronological age or provide a definitive basis for legal classification (2)(3)(4). This creates a tension between administrative demands for a clear-cut answer and the physician's responsibility to communicate the limitations of the available evidence. Under the Italian Code of Medical Ethics, physicians must exercise their professional activity with independence, autonomy, and responsibility, guided by the protection of patients' health and adherence to professional standards (13).When scientific uncertainty cannot be eliminated, ethical practice requires proportionality between the information sought and the burdens of assessment. Beneficence and non-maleficence therefore require clinicians to avoid examinations unlikely to provide meaningful information while exposing children to unnecessary procedures or distress.The role of clinicians is not to determine legal status, but to provide a scientifically grounded assessment of health, development, and clinical needs while clearly communicating the inherent uncertainty of age estimation.The ethical responsibility of clinicians therefore extends beyond the technical performance and interpretation of medical examinations. Physicians should explain the limitations of the available methods, avoid presenting probabilistic estimates as definitive determinations, and ensure that their reports distinguish clinical findings from legal conclusions. Where the available evidence cannot establish chronological age with sufficient certainty, clinicians should communicate this uncertainty clearly to the competent authorities. This approach supports professional independence, reduces the risk of disproportionate reliance on medical testing, and helps ensure that decisions concerning children are informed by medical evidence without transferring legal decision-making to healthcare professionals.A participatory approach requires that children and adolescents receive clear, age-appropriate information, in a language they understand, about the purpose, procedures, limitations, and potential consequences of age assessment. They should be given a meaningful opportunity to express their views, explain their personal circumstances, ask questions, and have their perspectives taken into account in decisions affecting them, in accordance with their evolving capacities (5). Where necessary, qualified cultural mediators should facilitate communication, while legal representatives should help ensure that the child understands the procedure and can exercise their rights effectively.Participation should not be understood as a formality or as a substitute for scientific assessment; rather, it is a procedural safeguard that supports informed involvement, respect for the child's dignity, and decisions consistent with the child's best interests (5,14).In Italy, the 2024 Prime Ministerial Decree (Decreto del Presidente del Consiglio dei Ministri, DPCM No. 98/2024) regulates the interview conducted with unaccompanied foreign minors upon entry into first-reception facilities, establishing procedures intended to ensure appropriate listening and the collection of information relevant to the assessment of the child's best interests (14). These participatory safeguards are complementary to, but distinct from, the multidisciplinary procedure for age assessment established under the 2020 State-Regions Agreement (10).Age assessment should therefore remain a multidisciplinary process in which uncertainty is explicitly acknowledged and managed through appropriate procedural safeguards. Where uncertainty remains after multidisciplinary assessment, the principle of the benefit of the doubt should guide decision-making (5), particularly when the consequences of an incorrect classification may be irreversible or disproportionate.These considerations have become increasingly relevant since the Pact on Migration and Asylum entered into application on 12 June 2026 (15).The National Working Group on Migrant Children (GLNBM) of the Italian Society of Pediatrics (SIP) had previously urged Italian authorities to ensure full implementation of the 2020 State-Regions Agreement. With the Pact's entry into application, it reiterated these recommendations and additionally highlighted the risk that accelerated procedures and shortened timeframes could compromise comprehensive age assessment, identification of health and psychosocial vulnerabilities, and child-protection safeguards.Such pressures may also increase the risk of inappropriate accommodation or de facto detention, with potential consequences for physical and mental health, including for accompanied children where specific safeguards are lacking.As one of the major EU countries of arrival, Italy faces substantial pressures on its reception and child-protection systems. Spain provides a relevant comparative example. Its 2014 Framework Protocol on Unaccompanied Foreign Minors requires a prior personal examination before medical tests assessing skeletal or dental maturation and provides for medical reports to justify the examinations performed and specify an age range consistent with the associated margin of error (17,18). These provisions recognize the importance of individual assessment and explicit communication of uncertainty. However, the existence of a formal protocol does not in itself establish consistent implementation or eliminate the risk of overreliance on medical findings. A meaningful comparison between Italy and Spain should therefore consider not only the provisions governing age assessment, but also their implementation, access to multidisciplinary expertise, and the safeguards available to challenge decisions. Such a comparison would require further empirical evidence on national and regional practices.Effective oversight will be essential to ensure sufficient time and resources for comprehensive assessment when doubts about age arise, so that procedural efficiency does not undermine childprotection safeguards.In parallel with these European developments, Italy is considering changes to its national protection and reception framework.Senate Bill No. 1869, introduced on 14 April 2026, proposes amendments to the national framework governing immigration and international protection, including provisions affecting unaccompanied foreign minors. At the time of writing (29 October 2026), the bill was listed on the official website of the Italian Senate as being under examination by the 1st Standing Committee (Constitutional Affairs), with the latest recorded update to its parliamentary status dated 19 May 2026 (16). Among its proposed provisions, the bill would transfer responsibility for assisted voluntary returns from the juvenile court to the prefect, subject to prior authorisation by the juvenile court, and reduce the maximum duration of the administrative continuation measure (prosieguo amministrativo) from 21 to 19 years. If adopted, these changes could affect existing pathways of protection and continuity of support during the transition to adulthood.The prosieguo amministrativo allows established pathways towards autonomy and social integration to continue beyond age 18 following a decision by the juvenile court. Earlier termination of support could disrupt continuity of healthcare, education, housing, and supportive relationships during a sensitive developmental period, with consequences for psychosocial well-being and longer-term health trajectories.Age assessment lies at the intersection of clinical practice, legal decision-making, and child protection. significance extends beyond the estimation of chronological age, as the outcome may determine whether an adolescent can access safeguards and services specifically intended for children. The central issue is therefore not only the reliability of available methods, but also how scientific uncertainty is interpreted when decisions have substantial consequences for an individual's rights and well-being.From a clinical perspective, age assessment highlights the limits of medical evidence when biological maturation is used to inform legal decisions. Physicians have a responsibility to provide scientifically grounded assessments and communicate their limitations clearly, while recognizing that medical expertise cannot independently resolve the legal and social questions involved. This distinction is particularly important when an estimated age may influence access to protection or expose a young person to procedures intended for adults.Experiences in Italy and Spain suggest that even where formal legal frameworks recognise uncertainty and require multidisciplinary assessment, ensuring consistent implementation remains challenging. Differences in access to expertise, procedural safeguards, and multidisciplinary resources may continue to influence how age-assessment procedures are carried out in practice.Although national legal frameworks differ, these experiences underline the importance of evaluating age-assessment procedures not solely by their capacity to facilitate administrative decisions, but also by their ability to preserve appropriate safeguards for potentially vulnerable children. This requires continued dialogue between medicine, law, and child-protection practice.From a clinical and public health perspective, improvements should include standardized reporting of the limitations and uncertainty of age estimates, systematic monitoring of the use and outcomes of radiological examinations, and access to appropriately trained multidisciplinary teams and qualified cultural mediators. Radiological investigations, when justified within the applicable legal framework, should be selected on the basis of their expected clinical or assessment value, interpreted alongside other relevant information, and reported with explicit acknowledgment of their limitations. Medical reports should distinguish biological findings from conclusions concerning legal status. These measures would strengthen professional independence, improve transparency, and support more consistent, child-centred decision-making across regions.Ultimately, ensuring continuity of care means ensuring continuity of protection.
Authors
- Rosalia Marrone (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8205-5053)
- Piero Valentini (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6095-9510)
- Riccardo Bosi
- Ilaria Lazzareschi
Institutions
- Italian Society of Physiotherapy (IT)
- Società Italiana di Pediatria (IT)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Frontiers in Public Health
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2026.1994339
- Primary Topic
- Migration, Racism, and Human Rights
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00