Legal Consequences of Non-Fulfillment of Land Sale and Purchase Conditions for Bank-Collateralized Land: An Imam Nawawi Perspective (A Case Study of Bandar Pasir Mandoge)
This study examines the sale and purchase of land that remains encumbered as bank collateral in Bandar Pasir Mandoge. The dispute arose when the seller claimed that the land certificate had been lost, whereas subsequent verification revealed that the bank still held the certificate as debt security. Having already paid IDR 250,000,000, the buyer faced legal uncertainty due to the unresolved legal status of the land. This research aims to examine the practice of buying and selling land pledged as bank collateral, analyze the legal consequences of failing to fulfill the validity requirements of a sale contract (bay') from the perspective of Imam al-Nawawi, and identify the forms of legal protection available to the buyer. Employing an empirical legal research method with a case study approach, data were collected through interviews and library research encompassing books, scholarly journals, statutory regulations, and relevant Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) literature. The data were analyzed descriptively by correlating empirical findings with applicable legal provisions. The findings indicate that concealing information regarding the certificate’s status raises critical issues concerning honesty, transparency, and the mutual consent (taradhi) of the contracting parties. From Imam al-Nawawi’s perspective within the Shafi'i school (Mazhab Syafi'i), the validity of a sale must be assessed based on the fulfillment of contractual pillars (rukun) and conditions (syarat), clarity of the object, and the principle of good faith in muamalah. While the encumbered status of the land does not automatically render the sale contract void, the existing security interest and misrepresentation expose the buyer to significant legal risks. Legal protection for the buyer can be pursued through due diligence on the certificate and mortgage (Hak Tanggungan) status prior to the transaction, deliberation or mediation, and formal legal remedies under applicable laws. This study underscores the importance of information disclosure and prudence to ensure legal certainty and safeguard buyers' rights.
Authors
- Sudirman Suparmin (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0525-3958)
- Ayu Febrianti Adha
Institutions
- North Sumatra Islamic University (ID)
- Universitas Islam Negeri Sumatera Utara (ID)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Lex journal kajian hukum dan keadilan
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.25139/lex.v10i4.13069
- Primary Topic
- Legal Studies and Policies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00