Designing the climate agenda in the Global South: selective reconfiguration, institutional scaffolding, and policy entrepreneurship in Brazil’s National Climate Change Policy

This paper examines the agenda-setting of Brazil’s National Climate Change Policy (PNMC) across its first policy cycle (2009–2020) as a case of design-led governance under conditions of complexity. Rather than treating design as a metaphor for policy architecture, it foregrounds design as situated practice: the deliberate crafting of governance arenas and instruments, the brokerage performed by policy entrepreneurs, and the selective reconfiguration of governance-design templates as they circulate from multilateral and Global North arenas into a Southern political context. Combining Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework with complexity theory and design theory, the argument is formalized as a central hypothesis and five falsifiable propositions specifying the conditions under which circulating templates are selectively reconfigured rather than faithfully adopted, rejected, or symbolically maintained; the operational indicators that discriminate complexity mechanisms from rival accounts (political bargaining, institutional adaptation, policy translation, strategic agency); and the forms of reconfiguration predicted under different actor, resource, and volatility configurations. Empirically, the paper re-interprets a process-tracing study of the PNMC based on documentary analysis and 25 key-informant interviews, deploying the case as a plausibility probe. International influence—disaggregated into multilateral regime institutions, multilateral banks, bilateral Global North funders, and Global South coalitions—operated as a constitutive design variable: external finance exceeding R$20 billion anchored the generation of alternatives, while imported templates (the NDC, MRV systems, REDD+, sectoral plans) were reconfigured, their internationally legible scaffolds preserved and their content reshaped by a cross-ideological pact that pursued resource capture while vetoing domestic costs. A paired within-case comparison shows why SIRENE coupled in the midst of crisis while the NDC implementation strategy never reached the agenda. The same institutional repertoire that built the policy (2009–2018) was repurposed to dismantle it (2019–2020) at a cost inversely related to its institutionalization—a pattern that conversion and policy-dismantling accounts describe but do not predict. The case exposes both Southern agency in remaking circulating design frameworks and the structural asymmetries that constrain it, and derives comparative predictions for other Southern climate agendas.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Political Science
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpos.2026.1935774
Primary Topic
Policy Transfer and Learning
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Designing the climate agenda in the Global South: selective reconfiguration, institutional scaffolding, and policy entrepreneurship in Brazil’s National Climate Change Policy

Paulo Carlos Du Pin Calmon, Karen de Oliveira Silverwood-Cope, Tiago Barros Pontes e Silva
Frontiers in Political Science
Policy Transfer and Learning
article

Designing the climate agenda in the Global South: selective reconfiguration, institutional scaffolding, and policy entrepreneurship in Brazil’s National Climate Change Policy

Paulo Carlos Du Pin Calmon, Karen de Oliveira Silverwood-Cope, Tiago Barros Pontes e Silva
article en

Abstract

This paper examines the agenda-setting of Brazil’s National Climate Change Policy (PNMC) across its first policy cycle (2009–2020) as a case of design-led governance under conditions of complexity. Rather than treating design as a metaphor for policy architecture, it foregrounds design as situated practice: the deliberate crafting of governance arenas and instruments, the brokerage performed by policy entrepreneurs, and the selective reconfiguration of governance-design templates as they circulate from multilateral and Global North arenas into a Southern political context. Combining Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework with complexity theory and design theory, the argument is formalized as a central hypothesis and five falsifiable propositions specifying the conditions under which circulating templates are selectively reconfigured rather than faithfully adopted, rejected, or symbolically maintained; the operational indicators that discriminate complexity mechanisms from rival accounts (political bargaining, institutional adaptation, policy translation, strategic agency); and the forms of reconfiguration predicted under different actor, resource, and volatility configurations. Empirically, the paper re-interprets a process-tracing study of the PNMC based on documentary analysis and 25 key-informant interviews, deploying the case as a plausibility probe. International influence—disaggregated into multilateral regime institutions, multilateral banks, bilateral Global North funders, and Global South coalitions—operated as a constitutive design variable: external finance exceeding R$20 billion anchored the generation of alternatives, while imported templates (the NDC, MRV systems, REDD+, sectoral plans) were reconfigured, their internationally legible scaffolds preserved and their content reshaped by a cross-ideological pact that pursued resource capture while vetoing domestic costs. A paired within-case comparison shows why SIRENE coupled in the midst of crisis while the NDC implementation strategy never reached the agenda. The same institutional repertoire that built the policy (2009–2018) was repurposed to dismantle it (2019–2020) at a cost inversely related to its institutionalization—a pattern that conversion and policy-dismantling accounts describe but do not predict. The case exposes both Southern agency in remaking circulating design frameworks and the structural asymmetries that constrain it, and derives comparative predictions for other Southern climate agendas.

Frontiers in Political ScienceVol. 8
Universidade de Brasília (BR)
Climate action, Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Policy Transfer and Learning
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon