Beyond Fixed Evaluation: An Adaptive Self-Mutual-Human Evaluation Framework for Dynamic Selection, Switching, Combination, and Reconfiguration in Artificial Intelligence Systems

Evaluation is a fundamental function of artificial intelligence systems, enabling the assessment of answer quality, factual accuracy, reasoning validity, task performance, reliability, and overall suitability. Existing approaches include self-evaluation, in which an individual model evaluates its own outputs; model-based evaluation, in which other models assess the outputs of a target model; and human evaluation, in which human individuals provide judgments based on their knowledge, experience, and contextual understanding. Although these approaches have been investigated extensively, they are commonly implemented as separate evaluation strategies or within relatively fixed evaluation arrangements. A general framework capable of dynamically determining when a system should evaluate itself, request evaluations from other models, involve human evaluators, or combine these mechanisms remains an important research direction. This paper proposes the Adaptive Self-Mutual-Human Evaluation Framework (AS-MHEF), a functional extension of the Universal Self-Mutual-Human Model (USMHM). The framework establishes three fundamental evaluation dimensions: Self-Evaluation, in which a participant evaluates its own outputs or performance; Mutual Evaluation, in which multiple participants independently or collaboratively evaluate one another; and Human Evaluation, in which human individuals or groups assess outputs, processes, or decisions. Its central contribution is the integration of adaptive evaluation selection, dynamic mechanism switching, adaptive combination, and structural reconfiguration into a unified evaluation architecture. Unlike systems that permanently rely on one evaluation source, AS-MHEF enables an evaluation process to select self-evaluation for routine or sufficiently manageable tasks, activate mutual evaluation when independent perspectives or additional scrutiny are required, and introduce human evaluation when contextual judgment, unresolved disagreement, elevated uncertainty, or high-impact consequences justify human participation. It also supports simultaneous evaluation by multiple mechanisms, weighted or rule-based aggregation, repeated evaluation, and transitions between evaluation configurations during execution. A formal representation, adaptive decision policy, evaluation lifecycle, transition architecture, theoretical propositions, governance principles, and empirical research methodology are developed. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to formally propose a unified and mechanism-independent Self-Mutual-Human evaluation architecture that integrates self-evaluation, mutual evaluation, and human evaluation with adaptive selection, dynamic switching, combination, and reconfiguration as coordinated capabilities within the broader USMHM theoretical foundation. The framework provides a general conceptual basis for designing and analyzing evaluation systems that dynamically distribute evaluative responsibilities across heterogeneous artificial and human participants.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24338909
Primary Topic
Artificial Intelligence Applications
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Beyond Fixed Evaluation: An Adaptive Self-Mutual-Human Evaluation Framework for Dynamic Selection, Switching, Combination, and Reconfiguration in Artificial Intelligence Systems

Jincheng Zhang
5 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Artificial Intelligence Applications
preprint

Beyond Fixed Evaluation: An Adaptive Self-Mutual-Human Evaluation Framework for Dynamic Selection, Switching, Combination, and Reconfiguration in Artificial Intelligence Systems

Jincheng Zhang
preprint en

Abstract

Evaluation is a fundamental function of artificial intelligence systems, enabling the assessment of answer quality, factual accuracy, reasoning validity, task performance, reliability, and overall suitability. Existing approaches include self-evaluation, in which an individual model evaluates its own outputs; model-based evaluation, in which other models assess the outputs of a target model; and human evaluation, in which human individuals provide judgments based on their knowledge, experience, and contextual understanding. Although these approaches have been investigated extensively, they are commonly implemented as separate evaluation strategies or within relatively fixed evaluation arrangements. A general framework capable of dynamically determining when a system should evaluate itself, request evaluations from other models, involve human evaluators, or combine these mechanisms remains an important research direction. This paper proposes the Adaptive Self-Mutual-Human Evaluation Framework (AS-MHEF), a functional extension of the Universal Self-Mutual-Human Model (USMHM). The framework establishes three fundamental evaluation dimensions: Self-Evaluation, in which a participant evaluates its own outputs or performance; Mutual Evaluation, in which multiple participants independently or collaboratively evaluate one another; and Human Evaluation, in which human individuals or groups assess outputs, processes, or decisions. Its central contribution is the integration of adaptive evaluation selection, dynamic mechanism switching, adaptive combination, and structural reconfiguration into a unified evaluation architecture. Unlike systems that permanently rely on one evaluation source, AS-MHEF enables an evaluation process to select self-evaluation for routine or sufficiently manageable tasks, activate mutual evaluation when independent perspectives or additional scrutiny are required, and introduce human evaluation when contextual judgment, unresolved disagreement, elevated uncertainty, or high-impact consequences justify human participation. It also supports simultaneous evaluation by multiple mechanisms, weighted or rule-based aggregation, repeated evaluation, and transitions between evaluation configurations during execution. A formal representation, adaptive decision policy, evaluation lifecycle, transition architecture, theoretical propositions, governance principles, and empirical research methodology are developed. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to formally propose a unified and mechanism-independent Self-Mutual-Human evaluation architecture that integrates self-evaluation, mutual evaluation, and human evaluation with adaptive selection, dynamic switching, combination, and reconfiguration as coordinated capabilities within the broader USMHM theoretical foundation. The framework provides a general conceptual basis for designing and analyzing evaluation systems that dynamically distribute evaluative responsibilities across heterogeneous artificial and human participants.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Artificial Intelligence Applications
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon