Robust Optimization for Aggregate Transportation-Mode Allocation in Pharmaceutical Supply Chains under Delivery-Time Uncertainty: Evidence from SCMS Shipment Data

Pharmaceutical transportation-mode selection requires balancing freight cost and delivery-delay risk. This study develops an empirically calibrated robust optimization framework for aggregate pharmaceutical shipment allocation across modes, considering cost, delay risk, and a minimum quota of high-value shipments on reliable modes. The model uses 6,804 USAID Supply Chain Management System (SCMS) shipment records, mainly HIV-related commodities delivered during 2006–2015. Mode-specific weight-dependent freight-cost functions are validated against recorded expenditure; delay uncertainty is represented by a budgeted set calibrated from bootstrap estimation errors of mode-level mean positive delays. Ocean transport has the most severe upper tail (90th-percentile delay: 31 days), while ground transport has the highest lateness rate (20.7%). At Γ = 4, ocean transport is removed from the allocation; relative to Γ = 0, estimated freight cost increases by 1.9%, aggregate expected positive delay decreases by 11.7%, and the estimated on-time delivery rate rises from 86.3% to 86.8%, corresponding to approximately 33 additional consignments classified as on time among 6,146 shipments. Across 3,000 Monte Carlo scenarios and tested parameter perturbations, the robust allocation yields no greater delay than the deterministic allocation. In the 2013–2015 holdout, the allocations coincide; across four rolling-origin evaluations, average expected delay is 0.7% higher for the robust allocation. With composition-adjusted delay estimates, the ocean share remains 14.6% across Γ = 0–4, compared with 0% under the baseline robust allocation at Γ = 4. These results show that the cost–delay trade-off depends on the stability of modal delay patterns and shipment composition, highlighting the value of periodic recalibration. Findings are specific to one donor program.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Figshare
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35050192
Primary Topic
Supply Chain and Inventory Management
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Robust Optimization for Aggregate Transportation-Mode Allocation in Pharmaceutical Supply Chains under Delivery-Time Uncertainty: Evidence from SCMS Shipment Data

Javad Behnamian
Figshare
Supply Chain and Inventory Management
article

Robust Optimization for Aggregate Transportation-Mode Allocation in Pharmaceutical Supply Chains under Delivery-Time Uncertainty: Evidence from SCMS Shipment Data

Javad Behnamian
article en

Abstract

Pharmaceutical transportation-mode selection requires balancing freight cost and delivery-delay risk. This study develops an empirically calibrated robust optimization framework for aggregate pharmaceutical shipment allocation across modes, considering cost, delay risk, and a minimum quota of high-value shipments on reliable modes. The model uses 6,804 USAID Supply Chain Management System (SCMS) shipment records, mainly HIV-related commodities delivered during 2006–2015. Mode-specific weight-dependent freight-cost functions are validated against recorded expenditure; delay uncertainty is represented by a budgeted set calibrated from bootstrap estimation errors of mode-level mean positive delays. Ocean transport has the most severe upper tail (90th-percentile delay: 31 days), while ground transport has the highest lateness rate (20.7%). At Γ = 4, ocean transport is removed from the allocation; relative to Γ = 0, estimated freight cost increases by 1.9%, aggregate expected positive delay decreases by 11.7%, and the estimated on-time delivery rate rises from 86.3% to 86.8%, corresponding to approximately 33 additional consignments classified as on time among 6,146 shipments. Across 3,000 Monte Carlo scenarios and tested parameter perturbations, the robust allocation yields no greater delay than the deterministic allocation. In the 2013–2015 holdout, the allocations coincide; across four rolling-origin evaluations, average expected delay is 0.7% higher for the robust allocation. With composition-adjusted delay estimates, the ocean share remains 14.6% across Γ = 0–4, compared with 0% under the baseline robust allocation at Γ = 4. These results show that the cost–delay trade-off depends on the stability of modal delay patterns and shipment composition, highlighting the value of periodic recalibration. Findings are specific to one donor program.

Figshare
Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Supply Chain and Inventory Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon