Who Lost and Who Recovered during the Great Depression: An Eight Class and Life Cycle Analysis of Consumption Production Banking Institutions Income and Wealth Inequality and Keynesian Recovery in the United States
Purpose. To establish, class by class and age by age, who lost and who recovered during the American Great Depression of 1929-1941, and to ask how far different combinations of banking repair, monetary policy, Keynesian fiscal expansion and protection of basic needs could have changed those outcomes. Design. Retrieved national accounts, labour, banking, fiscal, price, demographic and distributional series (52 logged series) are combined with published top-income and wealth- concentration estimates to reconstruct an eight-class income distribution (percentile blocks 10/20/20/20/15/10/4/1) for every year from 1929 to 1941, a 60,000-unit synthetic population that is followed both as a fixed 1929 cohort and as re-ranked annual cross-sections, eight-by-eight age-by-class matrices, a class-by-asset wealth ledger, and needs shortfalls measured against the 1935 Works Progress Administration (WPA) emergency and maintenance budgets. A deviation model around actual history then evaluates eight policy packages (A actual to H integrated-but- captured) with Latin hypercube sensitivity analysis. Findings. Real GDP fell 26.3% from 1929 to 1933 (H) and unemployment reached 24.9% of the labour force under the BLS concept (H). In the reconstruction, real disposable income per person fell by 33% to 27% in classes 1 to 4 and by 40% in class 8 between 1929 and 1933; the share of persons below the WPA emergency budget rose from 21% to 34% (S). Income concentration at the very top fell during the slump and again after 1937, so the income Gini declined from 0.489 (1929) to 0.439 (1941) while needs deprivation first rose sharply. Without extraordinary intervention (package B) the model places 1933 output 11% below the actual level; earlier banking repair plus timely fiscal and needs support (package G) raises cumulative 1930-41 output by about $29 billion (1929 prices; 5th-95th percentile range -1 to 53) and cuts needs-shortfall person-years by 19 million. Originality. The paper keeps three things apart that are often merged: Keynes's own dated advocacy, the actual US measures with enactment, effective and disbursement dates, and hypothetical packages. It reports a Gini register across thirteen concepts with explicit “not identified” entries, nine joint income-wealth reference paths, and at least thirty-two class- and age-specific prescriptions. Limitations. The eight-class distribution is a reconstruction from grouped anchors; wealth by class is calibrated to concentration benchmarks rather than observed; the counterfactual model is a calibrated deviation model, not an estimated structural model, and its long-run results are sensitive to the investment accelerator and price-adjustment parameters.
Authors
- Muhmmad Muqeem Islam Muqeem (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-2005-4951)
Institutions
- National Institute for Public Policy (US)
- National School of Public Policy (PK)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11760280/v1
- Primary Topic
- Economic Theory and Policy
- Type
- preprint