Boundary detection and turning-point reliability in gridded water– carbon products
Gridded water–carbon products are used to infer transitions in vegetation responses to atmospheric dryness. We assessed the reliability of ET-conditioned VPD boundaries using eight-day PML evapotranspiration (ET) and gross primary productivity (GPP), together with ERA5-Land vapour pressure deficit (VPD), in Hetao croplands during 2019–2024. The observations represented 21,491 native PML cell–date units. Local boundaries persisted under equal source-unit weighting and single-record reconstruction. Correcting a prediction-basis inconsistency changed the turning geometry. All 1,000 block draws of the corrected weighted fit recovered a local boundary; 72.6% qualified an expansion–contraction turn, and the post-turn slope interval included zero. A separate spline refit also yielded an uncertain post-turn direction. Tests on 1,200 datasets with known boundaries showed that strict extraction reduced location error among qualified true turns while increasing missed and false turns. False-turn rates reached 42–44% for horizontal boundaries. Wetness-group comparisons were sensitive to eligibility within common support. Combining detection rates, conditional location error and block uncertainty provides a fuller assessment of transitions inferred from gridded products. In Hetao, the local response boundary was reproducible across the tested analyses, while the broader turning geometry remained uncertain.
Authors
- Duanguang Cao (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3529-1093)
- kang pian
- Xianzhi Wang¹
- Yanying Wang¹
- Jingwen Wang¹
Institutions
- Qilu Normal University (CN)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11571234/v1
- Primary Topic
- Plant Water Relations and Carbon Dynamics
- Type
- preprint