Comprehensive Finite Element Assessment of Seismic Performance in Steel Panel Zone Connections for Cruciform Columns Using Curved Plate Geometries

This study examines the structural performance of enhanced panel zone (PZ) configurations for flanged cruciform columns (FCCs) utilizing advanced finite element analysis in ABAQUS (v2022). A new bent panel zone (BPZ) connection—incorporating curved steel plates—is introduced and assessed in comparison to the previously established corrugated panel zone (CPZ) and a traditional web plate-only connection (WPZ). The BPZ consists of the column web plate and two additional load transfer paths formed by the column flanges and the bent plates connected to the edges of the flanges. Accordingly, three distinct shear force transfer mechanisms are established within the PZ. WPZ, although traditionally used in I-shaped columns and still permitted for cruciform columns, suffers from limited shear resistance due to the lack of participation of the orthogonal flanges and the occurrence of stress concentrations caused by excessive welding in this region. CPZ, while engaging the orthogonal flanges, also exhibits deficiencies because of the short straight load path and sharp corners at the junction with the column flanges, which lead to stress concentrations and an unfavorable distribution of shear forces. These shortcomings adversely influence the cyclic behavior and the shear capacity of the PZ. All three models underwent monotonic and cyclic loading, and their performance was evaluated based on key criteria: shear capacity, ductility ratio, energy dissipation, initial stiffness, and the ratio of post-yield to initial stiffness. The findings indicate that the BPZ connection significantly surpasses both CPZ and WPZ in all parameters, providing enhanced energy absorption, increased strength, and superior stiffness characteristics. Additionally, within the BPZ configuration, two geometric paths—bent path (BP) and accordion path (AP)—were analyzed separately, with the BP demonstrating better performance across all assessed metrics. Evaluations of stress contours based on von Mises and Tresca criteria, along with plastic strain distributions, validated the more advantageous stress pattern and reduced concentration levels in the BPZ model. The results indicated that at a 6% story drift, the shear capacity and energy dissipation of the BPZ were 12% and 20% higher than those of the CPZ, respectively. Its initial elastic stiffness was also 5% greater than that of the CPZ. In comparison with the WPZ, the BPZ exhibited substantially superior performance, with shear capacity and energy dissipation equal to 4.3 and 4.28 times those of the WPZ, respectively. These findings demonstrate the enhanced effectiveness of the BPZ as a PZ for cruciform sections.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Buildings
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings16224603
Primary Topic
Seismic Performance and Analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Comprehensive Finite Element Assessment of Seismic Performance in Steel Panel Zone Connections for Cruciform Columns Using Curved Plate Geometries

Ali Kazerani, Amir R. Masoodi
1 links
Buildings
Seismic Performance and Analysis
article

Comprehensive Finite Element Assessment of Seismic Performance in Steel Panel Zone Connections for Cruciform Columns Using Curved Plate Geometries

Ali Kazerani, Amir R. Masoodi
article en

Abstract

This study examines the structural performance of enhanced panel zone (PZ) configurations for flanged cruciform columns (FCCs) utilizing advanced finite element analysis in ABAQUS (v2022). A new bent panel zone (BPZ) connection—incorporating curved steel plates—is introduced and assessed in comparison to the previously established corrugated panel zone (CPZ) and a traditional web plate-only connection (WPZ). The BPZ consists of the column web plate and two additional load transfer paths formed by the column flanges and the bent plates connected to the edges of the flanges. Accordingly, three distinct shear force transfer mechanisms are established within the PZ. WPZ, although traditionally used in I-shaped columns and still permitted for cruciform columns, suffers from limited shear resistance due to the lack of participation of the orthogonal flanges and the occurrence of stress concentrations caused by excessive welding in this region. CPZ, while engaging the orthogonal flanges, also exhibits deficiencies because of the short straight load path and sharp corners at the junction with the column flanges, which lead to stress concentrations and an unfavorable distribution of shear forces. These shortcomings adversely influence the cyclic behavior and the shear capacity of the PZ. All three models underwent monotonic and cyclic loading, and their performance was evaluated based on key criteria: shear capacity, ductility ratio, energy dissipation, initial stiffness, and the ratio of post-yield to initial stiffness. The findings indicate that the BPZ connection significantly surpasses both CPZ and WPZ in all parameters, providing enhanced energy absorption, increased strength, and superior stiffness characteristics. Additionally, within the BPZ configuration, two geometric paths—bent path (BP) and accordion path (AP)—were analyzed separately, with the BP demonstrating better performance across all assessed metrics. Evaluations of stress contours based on von Mises and Tresca criteria, along with plastic strain distributions, validated the more advantageous stress pattern and reduced concentration levels in the BPZ model. The results indicated that at a 6% story drift, the shear capacity and energy dissipation of the BPZ were 12% and 20% higher than those of the CPZ, respectively. Its initial elastic stiffness was also 5% greater than that of the CPZ. In comparison with the WPZ, the BPZ exhibited substantially superior performance, with shear capacity and energy dissipation equal to 4.3 and 4.28 times those of the WPZ, respectively. These findings demonstrate the enhanced effectiveness of the BPZ as a PZ for cruciform sections.

BuildingsVol. 16(22)
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad (IR)
Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Seismic Performance and Analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon