Reconsidering ITLOS's Exercise of Discretion in Future Climate-Related Advisory Proceedings
This presentation reconsiders ITLOS’s exercise of discretion in future climate-related advisory proceedings, focusing on State consent and institutional circumvention. Through its interpretation of “matters” in Article 21 of its Statute in Cases Nos. 21 and 31, ITLOS has developed an advisory jurisdiction that, despite continuing controversy, is now largely established in practice. This jurisdiction nevertheless carries a risk of abuse. Although the advisory mechanism incorporates three layers of requirements or constraints, the first two can be circumvented with relative ease, leaving judicial discretion as the principal safeguard against abuse and a means of preserving the Tribunal’s judicial legitimacy. The paper argues that fundamental differences between ITLOS and the ICJ, particularly in their institutional mandates and the design of their advisory mechanisms, make an uncritical transplantation of the ICJ’s “compelling reasons” approach inappropriate. Instead, ITLOS should develop a more institutionally grounded approach, informed by its judicial role and the circumstances of each request. Whether particular considerations constitute compelling reasons to decline an opinion cannot be determined in the abstract, but depends on the questions presented and the context in which the request arises. Particular attention is given to Article 47(7) of the BBNJ Agreement, which establishes stringent conditions for advisory requests under that Agreement. Deliberate attempts to bypass these negotiated restrictions through separate international agreements may raise concerns about good faith and institutional circumvention capable of constituting compelling reasons for ITLOS to decline a request.
Authors
- Zhonghua Chen
Institutions
- China University of Political Science and Law (CN)
- Ghent University (BE)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24326951
- Primary Topic
- International Maritime Law Issues
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00