Beyond the Maximization of Well-Being: Generative-Resonance Economic Philosophy and the Depletion of Civilization's Generative Soil in the Age of AI ー From Economic Growth and Social Value to the Sustained Reopening of Human, Social, and Ecological P
1. Short Description This paper proposes a fundamental transformation in economic philosophy, moving beyond the maximization of GDP, happiness, health, or social value toward the sustained generation and reopening of human, social, and ecological possibilities. Drawing upon Generative-Resonance Theory, it distinguishes accumulated economic achievements from the living conditions that make future generation possible. It introduces generative soil depletion as a civilizational hypothesis: technological progress and economic prosperity may increase while independent human capabilities, relational participation, institutional adaptability, and ecological regeneration deteriorate. In the age of artificial intelligence, the central economic question is therefore not simply how much more intelligent technologies can produce, but whether economic institutions preserve the capacity of human beings and societies to discover new purposes, transform established relationships, and generate possibilities beyond existing measures of success. 2. Extended Description Modern economic thought has progressively expanded its conception of prosperity. Classical investigations of production, exchange, and wealth evolved into theories of capital accumulation, technological progress, human capital, institutional development, and endogenous growth. More recently, the limitations of gross domestic product as a measure of human flourishing have encouraged greater attention to happiness, health, substantive freedom, social relationships, environmental sustainability, and broader forms of social value. These developments represent substantial intellectual achievements. Nevertheless, this paper identifies a philosophical limitation that may persist even within multidimensional approaches to economic evaluation: the assumption that economic activity should ultimately be organized around the attainment or maximization of predetermined desirable outcomes. Generative-Resonance Economic Philosophy proposes a different starting point. Rather than treating human beings primarily as producers, consumers, or recipients of measurable achievements, it understands human existence as an ongoing relational process through which individuals and communities discover, revise, and generate purposes, values, capabilities, and forms of life. The framework introduces the conceptual movement: \[ \boxed{\Phi\rightarrow R\rightarrow G\rightarrow S\rightarrow\Phi'} \] Here, generative possibility (\(\Phi\)) develops through relational resonance (\(R\)), institutional mediation (\(G\)), and crystallized outcomes (\(S\)), before potentially reopening renewed generative possibilities (\(\Phi'\)). Economic achievements are consequently interpreted not as final purposes but as provisional elements within a continuing movement of human, institutional, and ecological transformation. The paper introduces generative soil depletion to describe a potentially consequential divergence between expanding economic performance and deteriorating conditions for future generation. A civilization may achieve increasing productivity, technological sophistication, and material prosperity while weakening independent learning, practical judgment, relational participation, institutional adaptability, or ecological resilience. Artificial intelligence intensifies the significance of this possibility. AI systems can improve task performance, accelerate knowledge-intensive production, and support scientific discovery. However, these achievements do not automatically establish that human beings and institutions are maintaining the capabilities necessary to investigate unfamiliar problems, challenge established objectives, or develop new forms of cooperation. Drawing upon classical political economy, growth theory, capability theory, pragmatism, institutional economics, ecological economics, and contemporary empirical research on AI, the paper reconstructs economic development as a relationship between present achievements and the regeneration of future possibilities. It further proposes a dynamic conceptual framework, identifies testable hypotheses, and examines implications for economic policy, corporate governance, education, social protection, environmental management, and intergenerational justice. The resulting paradigm shift is not a rejection of economic growth, mathematical analysis, institutional stability, or measurable well-being. Rather, it repositions these achievements within a broader philosophical understanding of human existence. The fundamental question becomes not what economic institutions should maximize, but what ongoing processes of human, social, and ecological generation they should sustain, protect, and enable to reopen. 3. Research Highlights - Beyond outcome maximization: Distinguishes the expansion of economic indicators from a fundamental transformation in the philosophical purpose of economic activity. - Generative-Resonance Economic Ontology: Introduces \(\Phi\rightarrow R\rightarrow G\rightarrow S\rightarrow\Phi'\) as a conceptual framework for understanding economic achievements within continuing relational and institutional becoming. - Generative soil depletion: Proposes a civilizational hypothesis in which measurable prosperity increases while human, relational, institutional, or ecological regenerative conditions deteriorate. - AI productivity versus human development: Distinguishes successful AI-assisted performance from the continuing development of independent learning, practical judgment, collective diversity, and organizational adaptability. - From growth accounting to regenerative dynamics: Separates the production of economic outcomes from the reproduction of the conditions supporting future economic and social generation. - Generative participation and justice: Extends distributive justice toward meaningful participation, self-determination, care, institutional contestation, and intergenerational responsibility. - Reversible institutional crystallization: Proposes that successful institutions combine reliable protection and coordination with legitimate mechanisms for questioning and transforming established objectives. - An empirical and self-critical research agenda: Identifies testable distinctions while recognizing that generative openness cannot be reduced to a universal performance score or a requirement for perpetual growth and change. 4. Chapter-by-Chapter Summaries Chapter 1. Introduction: From the Fruits of Growth to the Conditions of Generation The introduction establishes a distinction between accumulated economic achievements and the conditions required for their continued generation. Although economic growth has substantially improved material living standards, rising productivity and prosperity do not necessarily guarantee independent human development, meaningful relationships, or ecological regeneration. Artificial intelligence makes this distinction increasingly important by enabling sophisticated intellectual outputs without necessarily reproducing the human capabilities through which new knowledge and purposes emerge. The chapter introduces the central thesis: economic philosophy must move beyond maximizing established outcomes toward sustaining the processes through which future possibilities remain open. Chapter 2. The Historical Formation of Outcome-Oriented Economics This chapter reconstructs the historical development of economic thought through Adam Smith, industrialization, Marx, Polanyi, Solow, and Romer. It examines the relationship between Smith's moral and relational understanding of economic life, the abstraction of economic agency, critiques of institutional autonomy and commodification, and increasingly sophisticated explanations of measured economic growth. The chapter argues that explaining how knowledge, labor, capital, and institutions produce economic achievements is not equivalent to explaining how human beings and societies sustain the capacity to generate new purposes and possibilities. Chapter 3. Beyond GDP: The Expansion of Economic Value and Its Remaining Philosophical Problem This chapter critically examines the expansion of economic evaluation beyond GDP through the capability approach, pragmatist philosophy, ecological economics, and contemporary well-being research. Sen, Nussbaum, Dewey, Georgescu-Roegen, Ostrom, and other scholars provide important theoretical foundations for understanding substantive freedom, the transformation of purposes, institutional adaptation, and ecological interdependence. The chapter identifies a remaining philosophical question: whether the improvement of desirable states can adequately represent the open-ended processes through which human beings and communities discover, revise, and generate what they consider desirable. Chapter 4. The Reification of Economic Knowledge: When Models Become Purposes This chapter examines how economic abstractions, measurements, and institutional indicators may become increasingly detached from the lived processes they were originally intended to represent. Drawing upon Whitehead, Espeland and Stevens, and MacKenzie, it analyzes misplaced concreteness, commensuration, and the performativity of economic models. It introduces Hyper-S, represented by \(S\rightarrow S'\rightarrow S''\rightarrow\cdots\), as a conceptual framework for understanding the self-reinforcement of crystallized outcomes. The central argument is that measurement should remain an instrument of inquiry rather than becoming an unquestionable authority over economic and human purposes. Chapter 5. Generative-Resonance Economic Ontology: From Outcomes to Relational Becoming This chapter develops the ontological foundations of Generative-Resonance Economics. It contrasts the outcome-centered expression \(E=S\) with the generative-relational expression \(E=\Phi R\), emphasizing that human existence cannot be reduced to productivity, we
Authors
- Kazunori Ohumi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-3521-5554)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24342097
- Primary Topic
- Sustainable Development and Environmental Policy
- Type
- preprint