Cogent but Untested: Evaluating Argumentation in a Seriatim Constitutional Court

In constitutional courts that decide seriatim , each judge delivers an individual opinion and the ruling results from their aggregation. This article argues that, under this design, the critical discussion that would justify a collegial decision is structurally displaced: the difference of opinion is settled by vote rather than resolved on the merits, and argumentation addresses two audiences. Distinguishing the cogency of arguments from their critical testing in discussion, it shows that a decision may rest on cogent arguments that were never so tested. It proposes a three-layer multimethod instrument — structural analysis adapted from Manuel Atienza, evaluation drawn from informal logic, and a rhetorical analysis of the oral delivery of opinions in terms of strategic manoeuvring — and applies it to the ruling in which the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court equated homotransphobia with racism (ADO 26, decided in 2019). The results show scant dialectical interaction, untested central arguments and a predominance of ethos in oral delivery. The instrument can be applied to any court that decides by aggregating individual opinions.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11565015/v1
Primary Topic
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Cogent but Untested: Evaluating Argumentation in a Seriatim Constitutional Court

Douglas de Barros Ibarra Papa
Research Square
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
preprint

Cogent but Untested: Evaluating Argumentation in a Seriatim Constitutional Court

Douglas de Barros Ibarra Papa
preprint en

Abstract

In constitutional courts that decide seriatim , each judge delivers an individual opinion and the ruling results from their aggregation. This article argues that, under this design, the critical discussion that would justify a collegial decision is structurally displaced: the difference of opinion is settled by vote rather than resolved on the merits, and argumentation addresses two audiences. Distinguishing the cogency of arguments from their critical testing in discussion, it shows that a decision may rest on cogent arguments that were never so tested. It proposes a three-layer multimethod instrument — structural analysis adapted from Manuel Atienza, evaluation drawn from informal logic, and a rhetorical analysis of the oral delivery of opinions in terms of strategic manoeuvring — and applies it to the ruling in which the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court equated homotransphobia with racism (ADO 26, decided in 2019). The results show scant dialectical interaction, untested central arguments and a predominance of ethos in oral delivery. The instrument can be applied to any court that decides by aggregating individual opinions.

Research Square
Universidade Federal de Mato Grosso (BR)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Linguistics and Discourse Analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon