Effect of Micro-applicator on Universal Adhesives Bond Strength to Enamel
Objective To compare universal adhesives (UAs) shear bond strength (SBS) to enamel using different brands of disposable micro-applicators. Methods and materials Crowns of 216 bovine incisors were used, with their buccal enamel surfaces exposed and polished until 600-grit, and randomly assigned into 12 groups (n = 18). Two UAs with different solvents (ethanol for PeU.Peak Universal Bond Adhesive; or acetone, ethanol, and water for OpU.OptiBond Universal 360) were applied according to manufacturer’s instructions. Half of the specimens were applied as etch-and-rinse mode (ER) using 35% phosphoric acid (Ultra-Etch), while the other half were applied as self-etch mode (SE). On control groups, UAs were applied using their own disposable micro-applicator: a brush fibers tip (Ultradent Inspiral Brush Tip) for PeU or a micro-brush with fiber bristles (Kerr Applicators) for OpU. Also, UAs were applied using other 2 disposable micro-applicators: a fiber-free elastomer bristles (ZerofloX) or a general-brand micro-brush with fiber bristles (Aplik). UAs were light-cured for 10 sec using a LED (Valo). Composite cylinders 2.38 mm wide and 2.0 mm high were built (Filtek Z250 XT) and light-cured (20 sec) using an Ultradent Bonding Assembly. Specimens stayed in water (37 o C) for 6 months and then were subjected to thermal aging (10.000 cycles of 60 sec, 5 to 55 o C) prior to being subjected to SBS test. A hardened steel precise notch with Ø=2.38 mm semi-circular and 0.4 mm thick loaded the composite cylinders until fracture. The failure mode was analyzed under optical microscopy 40× and classified as: adhesive (AD), mixed (MI), cohesive in composite (CC), and cohesive in enamel (CE). To confirm failure mode, five specimens of each group were analyzed under SEM and EDX. Statistical analyses included ANOVA and Tukey HSD post-hoc test (α = 0.05). Enamel specimens from buccal and lingual surfaces of human molars (n = 3) were polished (up to 1,200-grit) and prepared for SEM analysis after the application of 2 bonding modes using the UAs. Results The mean SBS (± SD) ranged from 13.2 (± 3.8) MPa (SE.OpU.ZerofloX) to 39.7 (± 9.8) MPa (ER.PeU.Aplik). For both UAs, ER showed significantly higher SBS than SE (p < 0.001). PeU resulted in significantly higher SBS on enamel than OpU (p < 0.01). For OpU, ZerofloX resulted in significantly lower SBS than Kerr Applicators and Aplik (p < 0.005). There was no statistical difference between the mean SBS on enamel when PeU was applied with the 3 micro-applicators. MI failures predominated in ER groups. SE groups showed mainly AD failures. For SE, OpU resulted in featureless morphology resembling that of untreated enamel. PeU resulted in shallow intraprismatic etching. For ER, OpU and PeU displayed the classical phosphoric acid etching pattern on the entire surface. Conclusions UAs applied using ER mode resulted in higher SBS to enamel compared to SE. Elastomeric fiber-free micro-applicator reduced bond strength to enamel when the UA has the solvent acetone. Clinical Relevance Using the micro-applicator provided by the universal adhesive manufacturer is recommended. Elastomeric micro-applicator should not be used with acetone-containing universal adhesive.
Authors
- Guilherme Carpena Lopes (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1568-421X)
- Caroline Meurer
- Gustavo S. M. Oliveira
Institutions
- Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina (BR)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11636383/v1
- Primary Topic
- Dental materials and restorations
- Type
- preprint