Legal science field: Theory and history of state and law. History of legal doctrines TOWARDS A SOMATIC RIGHTS IMPACT ASSESSMENT: A HUMAN-RIGHTS-BASED MODEL FOR EVALUATING LAW, POLICY AND HEALTH TECHNOLOGIES IN UZBEKISTAN
Decisions about the human body are increasingly made through legal rules, administrative processes and digital infrastructures rather than through a single clinical intervention. Uzbekistan protects dignity, personal inviolability, privacy, personal data and health, while sectoral legislation regulates consent, reproductive health, psychiatric care and sensitive data. These guarantees, however, are applied through separate procedures that may overlook the combined physical and informational effects of a measure. This article develops a Somatic Rights Impact Assessment (SRIA) tailored to Uzbekistan. Doctrinal, formal-legal, comparative and systemic methods are combined with proportionality analysis and human-rights-based impact assessment. The study finds that regulatory impact assessment, health impact assessment, data protection impact assessment, algorithmic review and bioethical review each capture only part of the relevant risk. SRIA is therefore defined as an ex ante and continuing process for identifying, justifying and controlling interferences with bodily integrity, autonomy and body-related information. Its original contribution is an operational matrix that links legal basis, intensity, reversibility, consent, equality, data governance, oversight and remedies to three risk levels and five possible outcomes. The model can be incorporated as a specialised module within Uzbekistan’s existing rule-making review and as a pre-deployment condition for high-risk public health technologies. The principal recommendation is to introduce risk-based SRIA screening, independent multidisciplinary review for high-risk measures, proportionate publication and mandatory reassessment after material change.
Authors
- Istamova-Fayzullaeva Dilafruz Oybek kizi
Institutions
- Tashkent State University of Law (UZ)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Eurasian Journal of Law Finance and Applied Sciences
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.70413/ejlfas-v06-i11-a10936
- Primary Topic
- Medical and Health Sciences Research
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00