Using Artificial Intelligence to Evaluate the Quality of Narrative Feedback in Surgical Entrustable Professional Activities

BACKGROUND: Narrative feedback quality in surgical Entrustable Professional Activity (EPA) assessments is variable, limiting consistent evaluation and opportunities for improvement. We evaluated whether fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) could reproduce expert-assigned feedback quality scores and whether a simplified scoring rubric improved assessment consistency. STUDY DESIGN: This observational study evaluated 1,509 narrative comments from EPA micro-assessments in a general surgery residency program during the 2023-2025 academic years. Two surgical education experts scored feedback using the Quality of Assessment for Learning (QuAL) rubric, which assesses evidence, suggestion, and connection on a 0-5-point scale. A modified rubric (mQuAL) assigned 1 point per domain on a 3-point scale. Fine-tuned encoder and generative LLMs were evaluated using accuracy and F1 score against human-assigned scores. RESULTS: Overall interrater reliability was high (κ = 0.85), although raters disagreed on 27.8% of QuAL evidence scores. Binary evidence scoring with mQuAL reduced disagreement to 8.5%. Encoder and generative models achieved similar accuracy for suggestion (0.96 versus 0.94) and connection (0.95 vs 0.91), whereas the encoder outperformed the generative model for evidence (0.93 vs 0.77). Model performance was strongest with mQuAL. CONCLUSIONS: Fine-tuned LLMs reproduced expert assessments of surgical narrative feedback with high domain-specific accuracy, particularly using encoder models. Simplifying evidence scoring improved interrater agreement and model performance, supporting further evaluation of AI-assisted feedback quality assessment within surgical residency programs.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of the American College of Surgeons
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1097/xcs.0000000000002297
Primary Topic
Innovations in Medical Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Using Artificial Intelligence to Evaluate the Quality of Narrative Feedback in Surgical Entrustable Professional Activities

Jeremy A. Balch, George A. Sarosi, Benjamin Shickel, Tyler John Loftus et al.
3 links
Journal of the American College of Surgeons
Innovations in Medical Education
article

Using Artificial Intelligence to Evaluate the Quality of Narrative Feedback in Surgical Entrustable Professional Activities

Jeremy A. Balch, George A. Sarosi, Benjamin Shickel, Tyler John Loftus, Victoria Nolan, Jennifer H. Fieber, Sasank Desaraju, Michel S Kabbash
article en

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Narrative feedback quality in surgical Entrustable Professional Activity (EPA) assessments is variable, limiting consistent evaluation and opportunities for improvement. We evaluated whether fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) could reproduce expert-assigned feedback quality scores and whether a simplified scoring rubric improved assessment consistency. STUDY DESIGN: This observational study evaluated 1,509 narrative comments from EPA micro-assessments in a general surgery residency program during the 2023-2025 academic years. Two surgical education experts scored feedback using the Quality of Assessment for Learning (QuAL) rubric, which assesses evidence, suggestion, and connection on a 0-5-point scale. A modified rubric (mQuAL) assigned 1 point per domain on a 3-point scale. Fine-tuned encoder and generative LLMs were evaluated using accuracy and F1 score against human-assigned scores. RESULTS: Overall interrater reliability was high (κ = 0.85), although raters disagreed on 27.8% of QuAL evidence scores. Binary evidence scoring with mQuAL reduced disagreement to 8.5%. Encoder and generative models achieved similar accuracy for suggestion (0.96 versus 0.94) and connection (0.95 vs 0.91), whereas the encoder outperformed the generative model for evidence (0.93 vs 0.77). Model performance was strongest with mQuAL. CONCLUSIONS: Fine-tuned LLMs reproduced expert assessments of surgical narrative feedback with high domain-specific accuracy, particularly using encoder models. Simplifying evidence scoring improved interrater agreement and model performance, supporting further evaluation of AI-assisted feedback quality assessment within surgical residency programs.

Journal of the American College of Surgeons
University of Florida Health (US), University of Florida (US), Florida College (US)
Good health and well-being
Innovations in Medical Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon