Enhancing equity and resilience in coastal small-scale fisheries: a Confucian ethical perspective on community co-management

When trying to balance ecological protection with basic community livelihoods, coastal small-scale capture fisheries are facing serious governance challenges related to fairness, food security, and community resilience. Existing studies have focused on protecting rights, community participation, and the use of adaptive learning. However, further clarification is needed of how prioritizing basic needs, allocating responsibilities in light of participants’ differing circumstances, and reflecting on action can be ethically justified within a coherent framework. It is also necessary to show how these reasons can help participants understand and carry out their responsibilities. To address this ocean governance issue, this paper combines classical textual interpretation, conceptual analysis, and normative reasoning. It provides a modern explanation of “forming one body with all things,” “frugality,” and “self-cultivation through practice (shishang molian).” Through this, it builds a normative framework of relations, virtue, and practice to supplement the existing ethical arguments on co-management. The framework starts from concern for other people and marine ecosystems. It explains the ethical basis for limiting resource use, sharing conservation responsibilities, and reflecting on one’s own judgment. On this basis, it calls for respecting people’s right to participate, giving priority to basic needs within ecological limits, sharing responsibilities according to capacities, benefits, and the impacts of participants’ actions, and reviewing arrangements through joint learning. Based on this, the paper proposes four conditional propositions. These propositions concern the relationships between meaningful influence on decisions and perceived procedural fairness and governance trust; needs-based allocation and household food access; endorsement of restraint norms and compliance with fishing restrictions; and learning and feedback mechanisms and community resilience. Finally, the paper also suggests ways to test these propositions in future research. This paper links the ethical evaluation of co-management arrangements with how actors understand and carry out their responsibilities, providing an interconnected ethical basis for coastal fisheries governance. At the same time, the propositions still need empirical testing, and the choice of specific institutional arrangements and their application in different cultural contexts require further justification.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Marine Science
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2026.2018983
Primary Topic
Coastal and Marine Management
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Enhancing equity and resilience in coastal small-scale fisheries: a Confucian ethical perspective on community co-management

Jiayan Lu
3 links
Frontiers in Marine Science
Coastal and Marine Management
article

Enhancing equity and resilience in coastal small-scale fisheries: a Confucian ethical perspective on community co-management

Jiayan Lu
article en

Abstract

When trying to balance ecological protection with basic community livelihoods, coastal small-scale capture fisheries are facing serious governance challenges related to fairness, food security, and community resilience. Existing studies have focused on protecting rights, community participation, and the use of adaptive learning. However, further clarification is needed of how prioritizing basic needs, allocating responsibilities in light of participants’ differing circumstances, and reflecting on action can be ethically justified within a coherent framework. It is also necessary to show how these reasons can help participants understand and carry out their responsibilities. To address this ocean governance issue, this paper combines classical textual interpretation, conceptual analysis, and normative reasoning. It provides a modern explanation of “forming one body with all things,” “frugality,” and “self-cultivation through practice (shishang molian).” Through this, it builds a normative framework of relations, virtue, and practice to supplement the existing ethical arguments on co-management. The framework starts from concern for other people and marine ecosystems. It explains the ethical basis for limiting resource use, sharing conservation responsibilities, and reflecting on one’s own judgment. On this basis, it calls for respecting people’s right to participate, giving priority to basic needs within ecological limits, sharing responsibilities according to capacities, benefits, and the impacts of participants’ actions, and reviewing arrangements through joint learning. Based on this, the paper proposes four conditional propositions. These propositions concern the relationships between meaningful influence on decisions and perceived procedural fairness and governance trust; needs-based allocation and household food access; endorsement of restraint norms and compliance with fishing restrictions; and learning and feedback mechanisms and community resilience. Finally, the paper also suggests ways to test these propositions in future research. This paper links the ethical evaluation of co-management arrangements with how actors understand and carry out their responsibilities, providing an interconnected ethical basis for coastal fisheries governance. At the same time, the propositions still need empirical testing, and the choice of specific institutional arrangements and their application in different cultural contexts require further justification.

Frontiers in Marine ScienceVol. 13
Nanjing University (CN)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Life below water
Coastal and Marine Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon