THE CROSS-CRITERION FULFILMENT-EVALUATION DIVERGENCE THEORY (CCFEDT)

A single action, decision, policy, or system configuration may satisfy one criterion whilefailing another. The same outcome may be beneficial under one evaluative standard, harmfulunder another, permissible under a third, and unacceptable under a fourth. Such divergencemay arise from differences in objectives, constraints, thresholds, stakeholder interests, normativerules, resource allocation, causal dependencies, or measurement procedures. However, divergentevaluation does not by itself establish that fulfilling one criterion caused another criterion todeteriorate.This manuscript proposes the Cross-Criterion Fulfilment-Evaluation Divergence Theory(CCFEDT), a general framework for specifying criteria, identifying mandatory constraints,representing criterion-specific outcomes, detecting divergent evaluation, distinguishing descriptiveassociation from causal displacement, and making decisions under multiple non-equivalentstandards. Its default mechanism, the Cross-Criterion Trade-off and Evaluation DivergenceMechanism (CTEDM), contains six stages: criterion specification, prioritization, constraint andtrade-off analysis, cross-criterion impact assessment, divergence classification, and decision withfeedback.The primary illustrative case concerns an individual who steals food under severe resourcedeprivation and subsequently denies the act. The case demonstrates why immediate needsatisfaction, property-rights compliance, truthfulness, legal status, personal responsibility, andinstitutional responsibility must be evaluated separately. The case is not treated as the definitionof the general theory.The framework distinguishes hard constraints from negotiable objectives, ordinal judgmentsfrom cardinal measurements, threshold failure from total rejection, and evaluation divergence fromcausal displacement. It also identifies conditions under which weighted aggregation is inadmissibleor insufficient. Twelve hypotheses, a twenty-layer analytical architecture, a cross-domain map,boundary cases, a falsifiability plan, and a staged research protocol are specified. The workpresents a researchable conceptual architecture, not an empirically validated universal law. Itsoriginality, explanatory superiority, mathematical adequacy, and cross-domain generalizabilityremain open questions for systematic investigation.Keywords: criterion fulfilment; evaluation divergence; cross-criterion trade-offs; multi-criteriadecision analysis; causal displacement; normative evaluation; threshold constraints; decision theory;system dynamics; responsibility allocation

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24350080
Primary Topic
Multi-Criteria Decision Making
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

THE CROSS-CRITERION FULFILMENT-EVALUATION DIVERGENCE THEORY (CCFEDT)

Shamiul Hoque Shan
2 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Multi-Criteria Decision Making
preprint

THE CROSS-CRITERION FULFILMENT-EVALUATION DIVERGENCE THEORY (CCFEDT)

Shamiul Hoque Shan
preprint en

Abstract

A single action, decision, policy, or system configuration may satisfy one criterion whilefailing another. The same outcome may be beneficial under one evaluative standard, harmfulunder another, permissible under a third, and unacceptable under a fourth. Such divergencemay arise from differences in objectives, constraints, thresholds, stakeholder interests, normativerules, resource allocation, causal dependencies, or measurement procedures. However, divergentevaluation does not by itself establish that fulfilling one criterion caused another criterion todeteriorate.This manuscript proposes the Cross-Criterion Fulfilment-Evaluation Divergence Theory(CCFEDT), a general framework for specifying criteria, identifying mandatory constraints,representing criterion-specific outcomes, detecting divergent evaluation, distinguishing descriptiveassociation from causal displacement, and making decisions under multiple non-equivalentstandards. Its default mechanism, the Cross-Criterion Trade-off and Evaluation DivergenceMechanism (CTEDM), contains six stages: criterion specification, prioritization, constraint andtrade-off analysis, cross-criterion impact assessment, divergence classification, and decision withfeedback.The primary illustrative case concerns an individual who steals food under severe resourcedeprivation and subsequently denies the act. The case demonstrates why immediate needsatisfaction, property-rights compliance, truthfulness, legal status, personal responsibility, andinstitutional responsibility must be evaluated separately. The case is not treated as the definitionof the general theory.The framework distinguishes hard constraints from negotiable objectives, ordinal judgmentsfrom cardinal measurements, threshold failure from total rejection, and evaluation divergence fromcausal displacement. It also identifies conditions under which weighted aggregation is inadmissibleor insufficient. Twelve hypotheses, a twenty-layer analytical architecture, a cross-domain map,boundary cases, a falsifiability plan, and a staged research protocol are specified. The workpresents a researchable conceptual architecture, not an empirically validated universal law. Itsoriginality, explanatory superiority, mathematical adequacy, and cross-domain generalizabilityremain open questions for systematic investigation.Keywords: criterion fulfilment; evaluation divergence; cross-criterion trade-offs; multi-criteriadecision analysis; causal displacement; normative evaluation; threshold constraints; decision theory;system dynamics; responsibility allocation

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Multi-Criteria Decision Making
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon