Rethinking environmental justice through behavioural opportunity: developing a relational territorial vulnerability framework from IPSA-derived behavioural evidence

Environmental justice research has primarily explained health inequalities through environmental risks and resource distribution. Public spaces have similarly been assessed through quantity and accessibility, with planning interventions focused on optimizing resource allocation. However, this provision-oriented paradigm overlooks the behavioural dimension of spatial equity: health benefits depend on whether residents can translate public-space resources into stable, sufficient, and demand-responsive opportunities for health-supportive everyday activities. This limitation is particularly pressing in high-density cities, where spatial competition and socioeconomic inequality complicate the relationship between formal provision and actual use. We therefore reconsider environmental justice through the lens of behavioural opportunity. Drawing on theories of everyday public life and environmental affordance, we define Informal Public Space Activities (IPSAs) as self-initiated, stationary recreational, social, or physical practices occurring without formal programming or purpose-built facilities. Long-term IPSA observations reveal mismatches between residents' behavioural demands and existing public-space support conditions, identifying latent opportunity deficits that remain overlooked in conventional planning approaches. Based on that, vulnerability is reconceptualized as a relational condition arising from interactions between environmental risks and residents' behavioural demands, rather than from environmental exposure or demographic characteristics alone. Methodologically, this study introduces IPSA-derived behavioural opportunity inequalities into a city-scale territorial vulnerability assessment framework. We use Ward and Jaccard methods to identify territorial clusters with different environmental burdens and behavioural opportunity deficits in Hong Kong, a high-density case. Findings show that although isolated hotspots of environmental deficiency exist, areas characterised by compounded environmental and social vulnerabilities more clearly reveal priority locations for behavioural-supportive spatial interventions. The framework introduces a behavioural opportunity perspective into environmental impact assessment, making concealed behavioural inequalities assessable and extending environmental justice from exposure equity to behavioural opportunity equity. It further demonstrates how future public-space projects can integrate environmental risk mitigation with behavioural support, enabling differentiated planning, design, and governance responses across distinct territorial vulnerability contexts.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Environmental Impact Assessment Review
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2026.108817
Primary Topic
Environmental Justice and Health Disparities
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Rethinking environmental justice through behavioural opportunity: developing a relational territorial vulnerability framework from IPSA-derived behavioural evidence

Paulina Maria Neisch, Yuqi Jiang, Tong Cui, Maorui Xiong
1 links
Environmental Impact Assessment Review
Environmental Justice and Health Disparities
article

Rethinking environmental justice through behavioural opportunity: developing a relational territorial vulnerability framework from IPSA-derived behavioural evidence

Paulina Maria Neisch, Yuqi Jiang, Tong Cui, Maorui Xiong
article en

Abstract

Environmental justice research has primarily explained health inequalities through environmental risks and resource distribution. Public spaces have similarly been assessed through quantity and accessibility, with planning interventions focused on optimizing resource allocation. However, this provision-oriented paradigm overlooks the behavioural dimension of spatial equity: health benefits depend on whether residents can translate public-space resources into stable, sufficient, and demand-responsive opportunities for health-supportive everyday activities. This limitation is particularly pressing in high-density cities, where spatial competition and socioeconomic inequality complicate the relationship between formal provision and actual use. We therefore reconsider environmental justice through the lens of behavioural opportunity. Drawing on theories of everyday public life and environmental affordance, we define Informal Public Space Activities (IPSAs) as self-initiated, stationary recreational, social, or physical practices occurring without formal programming or purpose-built facilities. Long-term IPSA observations reveal mismatches between residents' behavioural demands and existing public-space support conditions, identifying latent opportunity deficits that remain overlooked in conventional planning approaches. Based on that, vulnerability is reconceptualized as a relational condition arising from interactions between environmental risks and residents' behavioural demands, rather than from environmental exposure or demographic characteristics alone. Methodologically, this study introduces IPSA-derived behavioural opportunity inequalities into a city-scale territorial vulnerability assessment framework. We use Ward and Jaccard methods to identify territorial clusters with different environmental burdens and behavioural opportunity deficits in Hong Kong, a high-density case. Findings show that although isolated hotspots of environmental deficiency exist, areas characterised by compounded environmental and social vulnerabilities more clearly reveal priority locations for behavioural-supportive spatial interventions. The framework introduces a behavioural opportunity perspective into environmental impact assessment, making concealed behavioural inequalities assessable and extending environmental justice from exposure equity to behavioural opportunity equity. It further demonstrates how future public-space projects can integrate environmental risk mitigation with behavioural support, enabling differentiated planning, design, and governance responses across distinct territorial vulnerability contexts.

Environmental Impact Assessment ReviewVol. 123
City University of Hong Kong (HK), University of Chinese Academy of Sciences (CN)
Sustainable cities and communities, Reduced inequalities, Good health and well-being
Environmental Justice and Health Disparities
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon