Canon in the classroom: a content analysis of strategic management textbooks

Strategic management textbooks play a key role in introducing and disseminating strategic concepts in management education; however, their pedagogical approaches remain underexplored. This study examines fundamental strategic management theories presented in six influential Anglophone textbooks, selected for their multiple editions, library holdings, and inclusion on prominent reading lists. Employing qualitative content analysis, we identified and coded 144 units across five dimensions: dominant theory, level of analysis, pedagogical framing, emphasis, and conceptual purpose. Intercoder reliability, measured via Krippendorff’s alpha, ranged from acceptable to strong (α = 0.690–0.877), with the lowest agreement observed for the level of analysis. Findings indicate that core pedagogical frameworks are primarily grounded in Industrial Organization theory and the Resource-Based View, with strategy analysis conducted predominantly at the firm level. Perspectives centered on institutions, critical approaches, and societal issues are comparatively underrepresented in favor of frameworks such as the Five Forces and the VRIO model, as well as planning approaches. In the sampled editions, sustainability and digital disruption appear as side topics rather than core ones. The study argues that textbooks significantly influence how students view competition, agency, and strategy. It also discusses implications for educators, publishers, and future research direction. Strategic management textbooks play a crucial role in shaping how future managers understand competition, resources, and responsibility, yet their educational approaches have received limited empirical evaluation. This study utilizes qualitative content analysis on 144 coded units from six prominent Anglophone textbooks. The analysis reveals that instruction remains primarily grounded in Industrial Organization and the Resource-Based View, with strategy predominantly examined at the firm level and theories often translated into managerial tools such as the Five Forces and VRIO frameworks. Institutional, critical, and societal perspectives are relatively underrepresented, while topics like sustainability and digital disruption are addressed as additions rather than being integrated into the core material. These findings assist educators in making informed decisions when selecting and supplementing textbooks and encourage authors and publishers to incorporate contemporary issues into the foundational principles of strategic management.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Figshare
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35046646
Primary Topic
Management and Marketing Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Canon in the classroom: a content analysis of strategic management textbooks

V. K. Ranjith, B. S. Arun, Abhishek S. K. P. Rao
Figshare
Management and Marketing Education
article

Canon in the classroom: a content analysis of strategic management textbooks

V. K. Ranjith, B. S. Arun, Abhishek S. K. P. Rao
article en

Abstract

Strategic management textbooks play a key role in introducing and disseminating strategic concepts in management education; however, their pedagogical approaches remain underexplored. This study examines fundamental strategic management theories presented in six influential Anglophone textbooks, selected for their multiple editions, library holdings, and inclusion on prominent reading lists. Employing qualitative content analysis, we identified and coded 144 units across five dimensions: dominant theory, level of analysis, pedagogical framing, emphasis, and conceptual purpose. Intercoder reliability, measured via Krippendorff’s alpha, ranged from acceptable to strong (α = 0.690–0.877), with the lowest agreement observed for the level of analysis. Findings indicate that core pedagogical frameworks are primarily grounded in Industrial Organization theory and the Resource-Based View, with strategy analysis conducted predominantly at the firm level. Perspectives centered on institutions, critical approaches, and societal issues are comparatively underrepresented in favor of frameworks such as the Five Forces and the VRIO model, as well as planning approaches. In the sampled editions, sustainability and digital disruption appear as side topics rather than core ones. The study argues that textbooks significantly influence how students view competition, agency, and strategy. It also discusses implications for educators, publishers, and future research direction. Strategic management textbooks play a crucial role in shaping how future managers understand competition, resources, and responsibility, yet their educational approaches have received limited empirical evaluation. This study utilizes qualitative content analysis on 144 coded units from six prominent Anglophone textbooks. The analysis reveals that instruction remains primarily grounded in Industrial Organization and the Resource-Based View, with strategy predominantly examined at the firm level and theories often translated into managerial tools such as the Five Forces and VRIO frameworks. Institutional, critical, and societal perspectives are relatively underrepresented, while topics like sustainability and digital disruption are addressed as additions rather than being integrated into the core material. These findings assist educators in making informed decisions when selecting and supplementing textbooks and encourage authors and publishers to incorporate contemporary issues into the foundational principles of strategic management.

Figshare
Quality education
Management and Marketing Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon