Fuzzy Fault-Tree Analysis of Hybrid Battery Thermal Management System of Electric Vehicles Using Phase Change Material (PCM)

The growing adoption of electric vehicles highlights the need for safe and reliable battery thermal management. Hybrid battery thermal management systems (HBTMSs) that combine phase change material (PCM) with liquid cooling improve thermal regulation but also increase reliability challenges due to added component complexity. This research applies fuzzy fault-tree analysis (FFTA) to a hybrid PCM liquid BTMS by extending a previously developed and evaluated deterministic fault tree into the fuzzy domain. Basic events with limited failure rate data are quantified using expert elicitation, linguistic variables, consistency-based weighting, and centre-of-area defuzzification. The baseline point-estimate top event probability is 0.150821 as a dimensionless conditional estimate under the adopted fault-tree structure and input assumptions, while fuzzy-bound propagation produces an uncertainty interval from 0.083095 to 0.276142, with a modal coordinate estimate of 0.150824. Complementary reliability analyses were conducted to examine dominant failure modes, uncertainty propagation, and opportunities for improvement. An additional fuzzy-spread and interval-sensitivity assessment distinguished the relative uncertainty of individual basic-event probabilities from their influence on the overall top event uncertainty, identifying BE10 and BE3 as the most influential events for reducing the propagated uncertainty interval. Sensitivity assessments involving alternative expert-weighting parameters and selected dependent basic-event pairs provided additional examination of the influence of modelling assumptions. Within the adopted model, PCM leakage in the tank and module received the highest reliability priority, followed by bearing failure, transducer drift, PCM degradation, relay inaction, and operational transients. The proposed framework provides an uncertainty-aware, action-oriented foundation for reliability-driven HBTMS design improvement.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
World Electric Vehicle Journal
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/wevj17110603
Primary Topic
Battery Modeling and Management
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Fuzzy Fault-Tree Analysis of Hybrid Battery Thermal Management System of Electric Vehicles Using Phase Change Material (PCM)

Mohammad Asjad, Rajeev Kumar, Shujaat Husain, Haroon Ashfaq et al.
4 links
World Electric Vehicle Journal
Battery Modeling and Management
article

Fuzzy Fault-Tree Analysis of Hybrid Battery Thermal Management System of Electric Vehicles Using Phase Change Material (PCM)

Mohammad Asjad, Rajeev Kumar, Shujaat Husain, Haroon Ashfaq, PRATIBHA KUMARI, Akhilesh Singh
article en

Abstract

The growing adoption of electric vehicles highlights the need for safe and reliable battery thermal management. Hybrid battery thermal management systems (HBTMSs) that combine phase change material (PCM) with liquid cooling improve thermal regulation but also increase reliability challenges due to added component complexity. This research applies fuzzy fault-tree analysis (FFTA) to a hybrid PCM liquid BTMS by extending a previously developed and evaluated deterministic fault tree into the fuzzy domain. Basic events with limited failure rate data are quantified using expert elicitation, linguistic variables, consistency-based weighting, and centre-of-area defuzzification. The baseline point-estimate top event probability is 0.150821 as a dimensionless conditional estimate under the adopted fault-tree structure and input assumptions, while fuzzy-bound propagation produces an uncertainty interval from 0.083095 to 0.276142, with a modal coordinate estimate of 0.150824. Complementary reliability analyses were conducted to examine dominant failure modes, uncertainty propagation, and opportunities for improvement. An additional fuzzy-spread and interval-sensitivity assessment distinguished the relative uncertainty of individual basic-event probabilities from their influence on the overall top event uncertainty, identifying BE10 and BE3 as the most influential events for reducing the propagated uncertainty interval. Sensitivity assessments involving alternative expert-weighting parameters and selected dependent basic-event pairs provided additional examination of the influence of modelling assumptions. Within the adopted model, PCM leakage in the tank and module received the highest reliability priority, followed by bearing failure, transducer drift, PCM degradation, relay inaction, and operational transients. The proposed framework provides an uncertainty-aware, action-oriented foundation for reliability-driven HBTMS design improvement.

World Electric Vehicle JournalVol. 17(11)
Institute of Management Technology (IN), Uttarakhand Technical University (IN), Jamia Millia Islamia (IN)
Affordable and clean energy
Battery Modeling and Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon