Fake Reviews as Digital Disinformation in Tourism Platforms: A Criminological Model of Trust and Reputational Manipulation

Objective : to develop a criminological model of fake reviews on digital travel platforms as a specific form of commercial misinformation that explains the mechanisms of transformation of false content into aggregated reputational data and identifies the directions for strengthening the information integrity of assessment systems. Methods : the methodological basis of the research was an integrative interdisciplinary approach based on scientific works in the field of digital platforms, tourism, consumer behavior, information systems, criminology and consumer protection law. Special tools are the criminological theory of routine activities (used as to analyze the structure and deficits of guidance opportunities in the digital environment) and the methods of iterative thematic comparison and conceptual mapping (used to differentiate organizational forms of reputation manipulation). Results : it was found that the structural vulnerability of consumers in the digital travel services market is due to the uncertainty of product quality up to the time of purchase, the dependence of choice on the indirect experience of third parties, and the asymmetry of information in the absence of reviewer verification tools. It is proved that the criminological significance of fake reviews is determined not by the fact of publishing a single false judgment, but by its interaction with the algorithmic architecture of the platform, which aggregates ratings into numerical ratings, popularity indices, and ranked output. Organizational forms of falsification are identified: from episodic individual actions to customized campaigns, brokerage intermediation, and coordinated network structures. Scientific novelty : a five-component criminological model of the functioning of fake reviews was constructed, covering the conditions of the digital environment and supervision, production and organizational forms of manipulation, algorithmic conversion of content by the platform, visibility and feedback within the platform, as well as behavioral, reputational and informational consequences. An analytical distinction was made between the potential negative effects of disinformation, empirically verifiable damage and legally recognized victimization. The study proved that it is inadmissible to automatically equate any falsification of reviews with organized cybercrime. Practical significance : the proposed conceptual model forms a methodological basis for digital platform operators, tourism industry entities, government regulators and consumer protection authorities in developing proportionate strategies to prevent platform fraud. The transition to a distributed monitoring system is proposed, combining transaction confirmation, behavioral and network analysis of accounts, transparent moderation, accessible appeal procedures and independent audit of algorithms, as well as a legal ban on the circulation of paid reviews.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Digital Technologies and Law
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21202/jdtl.2026.17
Primary Topic
Misinformation and Its Impacts
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Fake Reviews as Digital Disinformation in Tourism Platforms: A Criminological Model of Trust and Reputational Manipulation

Spyropoulos F.
Journal of Digital Technologies and Law
Misinformation and Its Impacts
article

Fake Reviews as Digital Disinformation in Tourism Platforms: A Criminological Model of Trust and Reputational Manipulation

Spyropoulos F.
article en

Abstract

Objective : to develop a criminological model of fake reviews on digital travel platforms as a specific form of commercial misinformation that explains the mechanisms of transformation of false content into aggregated reputational data and identifies the directions for strengthening the information integrity of assessment systems. Methods : the methodological basis of the research was an integrative interdisciplinary approach based on scientific works in the field of digital platforms, tourism, consumer behavior, information systems, criminology and consumer protection law. Special tools are the criminological theory of routine activities (used as to analyze the structure and deficits of guidance opportunities in the digital environment) and the methods of iterative thematic comparison and conceptual mapping (used to differentiate organizational forms of reputation manipulation). Results : it was found that the structural vulnerability of consumers in the digital travel services market is due to the uncertainty of product quality up to the time of purchase, the dependence of choice on the indirect experience of third parties, and the asymmetry of information in the absence of reviewer verification tools. It is proved that the criminological significance of fake reviews is determined not by the fact of publishing a single false judgment, but by its interaction with the algorithmic architecture of the platform, which aggregates ratings into numerical ratings, popularity indices, and ranked output. Organizational forms of falsification are identified: from episodic individual actions to customized campaigns, brokerage intermediation, and coordinated network structures. Scientific novelty : a five-component criminological model of the functioning of fake reviews was constructed, covering the conditions of the digital environment and supervision, production and organizational forms of manipulation, algorithmic conversion of content by the platform, visibility and feedback within the platform, as well as behavioral, reputational and informational consequences. An analytical distinction was made between the potential negative effects of disinformation, empirically verifiable damage and legally recognized victimization. The study proved that it is inadmissible to automatically equate any falsification of reviews with organized cybercrime. Practical significance : the proposed conceptual model forms a methodological basis for digital platform operators, tourism industry entities, government regulators and consumer protection authorities in developing proportionate strategies to prevent platform fraud. The transition to a distributed monitoring system is proposed, combining transaction confirmation, behavioral and network analysis of accounts, transparent moderation, accessible appeal procedures and independent audit of algorithms, as well as a legal ban on the circulation of paid reviews.

Journal of Digital Technologies and LawVol. 4(3)
Misinformation and Its Impacts
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon