ҚАЗАҚСТАННЫҢ БІР ПАЛАТАЛЫ ПАРЛАМЕНТІНДЕГІ ЦИФРЛЫҚ ДЕМОКРАТИЯ: АЗАМАТТАРДЫҢ ЗАҢ ШЫҒАРУҒА ҚАТЫСУЫНЫҢ КОНСТИТУЦИЯЛЫҚ МОДЕЛІ

Under the 2026 Constitution, legislative power is concentrated in the unicameral Kurultai, which calls for rethinking how citizens’ proposals reach a bill: without the filter of a second chamber, external public scrutiny becomes an important safeguard of legislative quality and accountability. Yet the eOtinish, ePetition.kz and Open Legal Acts portals receive proposals without systematically showing their link to a specific bill or the outcome of their consideration. The article aims to develop a legal model linking the registration of a civic proposal, referral to a competent body, substantive consideration and communication of the reasons for a decision. The normative materials comprise the Constitution, the Constitutional Law on the Kurultai, the laws on access to information and on legal acts, and the petition provisions of the Administrative Procedural and Process Code. The study applies formal legal, systemic and comparative methods and compares citizen initiatives and collective proposals in Finland and Estonia, both of which have unicameral parliaments. It finds that the common gap of the existing national mechanisms is the inability to trace what happens to a proposal; the public discussion of the 2026 draft Constitution illustrates this finding. The main result is a staged model combining a permanent registration identifier, a link to a specific bill version, a reasoned response and review of procedural barriers, together with five specific provisions for the Constitutional Law on the Kurultai. The model guarantees substantive consideration without granting citizens a right to compel enactment and without altering the list of subjects of legislative initiative under Article 60 of the Constitution. The conclusions rest on normative analysis; assessing the model’s effectiveness requires subsequent applied research. Keywords: digital democracy; unicameral parliament; citizen participation; legislative initiative; constitutional safeguards.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.26577/japj204111326
Primary Topic
Legal and Policy Issues
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

ҚАЗАҚСТАННЫҢ БІР ПАЛАТАЛЫ ПАРЛАМЕНТІНДЕГІ ЦИФРЛЫҚ ДЕМОКРАТИЯ: АЗАМАТТАРДЫҢ ЗАҢ ШЫҒАРУҒА ҚАТЫСУЫНЫҢ КОНСТИТУЦИЯЛЫҚ МОДЕЛІ

Е.Е. Мұрат
Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
Legal and Policy Issues
article

ҚАЗАҚСТАННЫҢ БІР ПАЛАТАЛЫ ПАРЛАМЕНТІНДЕГІ ЦИФРЛЫҚ ДЕМОКРАТИЯ: АЗАМАТТАРДЫҢ ЗАҢ ШЫҒАРУҒА ҚАТЫСУЫНЫҢ КОНСТИТУЦИЯЛЫҚ МОДЕЛІ

Е.Е. Мұрат
article en

Abstract

Under the 2026 Constitution, legislative power is concentrated in the unicameral Kurultai, which calls for rethinking how citizens’ proposals reach a bill: without the filter of a second chamber, external public scrutiny becomes an important safeguard of legislative quality and accountability. Yet the eOtinish, ePetition.kz and Open Legal Acts portals receive proposals without systematically showing their link to a specific bill or the outcome of their consideration. The article aims to develop a legal model linking the registration of a civic proposal, referral to a competent body, substantive consideration and communication of the reasons for a decision. The normative materials comprise the Constitution, the Constitutional Law on the Kurultai, the laws on access to information and on legal acts, and the petition provisions of the Administrative Procedural and Process Code. The study applies formal legal, systemic and comparative methods and compares citizen initiatives and collective proposals in Finland and Estonia, both of which have unicameral parliaments. It finds that the common gap of the existing national mechanisms is the inability to trace what happens to a proposal; the public discussion of the 2026 draft Constitution illustrates this finding. The main result is a staged model combining a permanent registration identifier, a link to a specific bill version, a reasoned response and review of procedural barriers, together with five specific provisions for the Constitutional Law on the Kurultai. The model guarantees substantive consideration without granting citizens a right to compel enactment and without altering the list of subjects of legislative initiative under Article 60 of the Constitution. The conclusions rest on normative analysis; assessing the model’s effectiveness requires subsequent applied research. Keywords: digital democracy; unicameral parliament; citizen participation; legislative initiative; constitutional safeguards.

Journal of actual problems of jurisprudenceVol. 120(4)
Legal and Policy Issues
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon