Trials as implementation context: a longitudinal qualitative study of the normalization of a decision aid for infant hip dysplasia

Background This paper traces the shifting conditions for normalization of a new technology for use in primary care: from initial skepticism, through routine use as a research intervention, to partial confidence in post-trial continuation. The technology, a decision aid for General Practitioners (GPs) to support diagnosis of, and appropriate referral for, infant developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH), was refined in a pilot study, and its effectiveness evaluated in HipDyS, a randomized controlled trial. Methods Comparison of qualitative data from semi-structured interviews ( n = 52 overall) with 48 participating clinicians at three time points (the pre-trial pilot study; 3 months after and 18 months after trial initiation) and observations in the development phase ( n = 35 consultations), from a qualitive study embedded in the HipDyS process evaluation. Data analysis drew on Normalization Process Theory. Results In the pilot study, GPs were skeptical of the likely integration of the diagnostic aid, perceiving it incongruent with primary care goals and driven primarily by the needs of orthopaedic surgeons who lacked understanding of primary care. After three months, the aid was described as normalized in practice within the trial, but unlikely to be integrated into routine care, given lack of coherence with (non-research) primary care contexts. At trial end, GPs described the diagnostic aid as, largely, one they would continue to use and champion with colleagues, though not as having significantly changed practices. Orthopaedic surgeons were largely unaware of the trial and did not consider GP’s referral behaviour to be a key issue for improving DDH diagnosis. For GPs, the framing of the aid as aligned with the needs of primary care research, but not necessarily with those of routine practice, shaped their cognitive participation and the coherence of new practices such that they could be normalized as trial interventions. Conclusion Comparing data across three time points highlights how the context of research, particularly the assumed ‘ownership’ of an intervention, shapes conditions of normalization, particularly key aspects of legitimation, coherence, and cognitive participation. In this case, neither prior legitimation nor alignment of goals across actors in primary and secondary care were necessary conditions for normalization. Trial registration number NCT04101903 (registration date 2019-09-23).

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Implementation Science Communications
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s43058-026-01182-9
Primary Topic
Health Policy Implementation Science
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Trials as implementation context: a longitudinal qualitative study of the normalization of a decision aid for infant hip dysplasia

Angel Chater, Hayley Redman, John Green, Andreas Roposch et al.
Implementation Science Communications
Health Policy Implementation Science
article

Trials as implementation context: a longitudinal qualitative study of the normalization of a decision aid for infant hip dysplasia

Angel Chater, Hayley Redman, John Green, Andreas Roposch, Sarah Milton, Gill Gilworth
article en

Abstract

Background This paper traces the shifting conditions for normalization of a new technology for use in primary care: from initial skepticism, through routine use as a research intervention, to partial confidence in post-trial continuation. The technology, a decision aid for General Practitioners (GPs) to support diagnosis of, and appropriate referral for, infant developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH), was refined in a pilot study, and its effectiveness evaluated in HipDyS, a randomized controlled trial. Methods Comparison of qualitative data from semi-structured interviews ( n = 52 overall) with 48 participating clinicians at three time points (the pre-trial pilot study; 3 months after and 18 months after trial initiation) and observations in the development phase ( n = 35 consultations), from a qualitive study embedded in the HipDyS process evaluation. Data analysis drew on Normalization Process Theory. Results In the pilot study, GPs were skeptical of the likely integration of the diagnostic aid, perceiving it incongruent with primary care goals and driven primarily by the needs of orthopaedic surgeons who lacked understanding of primary care. After three months, the aid was described as normalized in practice within the trial, but unlikely to be integrated into routine care, given lack of coherence with (non-research) primary care contexts. At trial end, GPs described the diagnostic aid as, largely, one they would continue to use and champion with colleagues, though not as having significantly changed practices. Orthopaedic surgeons were largely unaware of the trial and did not consider GP’s referral behaviour to be a key issue for improving DDH diagnosis. For GPs, the framing of the aid as aligned with the needs of primary care research, but not necessarily with those of routine practice, shaped their cognitive participation and the coherence of new practices such that they could be normalized as trial interventions. Conclusion Comparing data across three time points highlights how the context of research, particularly the assumed ‘ownership’ of an intervention, shapes conditions of normalization, particularly key aspects of legitimation, coherence, and cognitive participation. In this case, neither prior legitimation nor alignment of goals across actors in primary and secondary care were necessary conditions for normalization. Trial registration number NCT04101903 (registration date 2019-09-23).

Implementation Science Communications
University of Bedfordshire (GB), King's College London (GB), University of Exeter (GB), Wellcome Centre of Cultures and Environments of Health (GB), University College London (GB)
National Institute for Health and Care Research, NIHR Great Ormond Street Hospital Biomedical Research Centre
Good health and well-being
Health Policy Implementation Science
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon