Beyond Physical Reconstruction: Mapping the Documented Regeneration Coherence Gap Across Nested Scales in Post-Earthquake Valnerina, Italy

Post-earthquake reconstruction can restore buildings and infrastructure without demonstrating broader territorial regeneration. This study proposes a non-compensatory and scale-explicit framework connecting risk reduction, cultural heritage conservation, land-use sustainability, socio-economic recovery, community resilience, and multilevel governance. The framework distinguishes strategic intention, documented delivery, contextual observation, and verified regeneration outcome and defines the documented regeneration coherence gap as an unverified, partial, or inconsistent evidentiary connection among these stages. Such a gap is not interpreted as proof that regeneration has failed or that territorial outcomes have not occurred. The framework is applied through an embedded single-case study comprising the Umbrian Valnerina, Valle Castoriana, and Piedivalle. The final corpus comprises 19 sources and 28 scale-specific coding units: 17 strategic intentions, five documented delivery records, and six contextual observations; no unit met the criteria for a verified regeneration outcome. Blind second coding of all 28 units produced perfect agreement for analytical role and evidence maturity, strong agreement for primary framework dimension and scale class, and lower reproducibility for relational effect (20/28 exact agreement; Cohen’s κ = 0.553; Gwet’s AC1 = 0.639). Scale-specific profiles show that Piedivalle primarily documents multidimensional site-level intentions, whereas delivery evidence concerns broader reconstruction and programme governance; these materials are not interpreted as successive stages of the same intervention. Because no coding unit met the criteria for a verified regeneration outcome, all outcome-dependent specifications remained structurally incomplete. The informative sensitivity analyses therefore concerned intention and delivery coverage, territorial-scale matching, primary-versus-linked dimensions, and the exclusion of the project-authored source. The framework therefore provides a reproducible evidence-mapping protocol rather than a causal evaluation of regeneration effectiveness.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Sustainability
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/su182211717
Primary Topic
Earthquake and Disaster Impact Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Beyond Physical Reconstruction: Mapping the Documented Regeneration Coherence Gap Across Nested Scales in Post-Earthquake Valnerina, Italy

Paolo Verducci, Manuela Cecconi, Davide Berardi, Mara Lombardi
Sustainability
Earthquake and Disaster Impact Studies
article

Beyond Physical Reconstruction: Mapping the Documented Regeneration Coherence Gap Across Nested Scales in Post-Earthquake Valnerina, Italy

Paolo Verducci, Manuela Cecconi, Davide Berardi, Mara Lombardi
article en

Abstract

Post-earthquake reconstruction can restore buildings and infrastructure without demonstrating broader territorial regeneration. This study proposes a non-compensatory and scale-explicit framework connecting risk reduction, cultural heritage conservation, land-use sustainability, socio-economic recovery, community resilience, and multilevel governance. The framework distinguishes strategic intention, documented delivery, contextual observation, and verified regeneration outcome and defines the documented regeneration coherence gap as an unverified, partial, or inconsistent evidentiary connection among these stages. Such a gap is not interpreted as proof that regeneration has failed or that territorial outcomes have not occurred. The framework is applied through an embedded single-case study comprising the Umbrian Valnerina, Valle Castoriana, and Piedivalle. The final corpus comprises 19 sources and 28 scale-specific coding units: 17 strategic intentions, five documented delivery records, and six contextual observations; no unit met the criteria for a verified regeneration outcome. Blind second coding of all 28 units produced perfect agreement for analytical role and evidence maturity, strong agreement for primary framework dimension and scale class, and lower reproducibility for relational effect (20/28 exact agreement; Cohen’s κ = 0.553; Gwet’s AC1 = 0.639). Scale-specific profiles show that Piedivalle primarily documents multidimensional site-level intentions, whereas delivery evidence concerns broader reconstruction and programme governance; these materials are not interpreted as successive stages of the same intervention. Because no coding unit met the criteria for a verified regeneration outcome, all outcome-dependent specifications remained structurally incomplete. The informative sensitivity analyses therefore concerned intention and delivery coverage, territorial-scale matching, primary-versus-linked dimensions, and the exclusion of the project-authored source. The framework therefore provides a reproducible evidence-mapping protocol rather than a causal evaluation of regeneration effectiveness.

SustainabilityVol. 18(22)
University of Perugia (IT), Sapienza University of Rome (IT)
Sustainable cities and communities
Earthquake and Disaster Impact Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon