De Gustibus Gravidarum: Pregnancy, Stable Preferences, and the Four Clocks of Household Demand

Pregnancy is the hardest case for the Stigler–Becker doctrine that tastes are stable and that observed changes in demand reflect changes in constraints, prices and household technology. A single before-and-after comparison cannot adjudicate the issue, because any change in a demand vector can be rationalized either by a shift in tastes or by a shift in shadow prices. This paper argues that timing can. Gestation is governed by four clocks that start at different dates and leave different signatures in expenditure: an information clock that starts when the pregnancy is recognized, a physiological clock that runs continuously, an option clock that starts when the risk of pregnancy loss resolves, and a deadline clock that ends at the birth. A household production model with fixed preferences delivers distinct timing predictions for harm goods, food, irreversible child durables and home readiness goods, and a non-identification result for designs that ignore timing. The predictions are tested on 1,164 births identified in the rotating panel of the U.S. Consumer Expenditure Interview Survey (2007–2025), using monthly expenditure records and event-study regressions with household and calendar-month fixed effects against 35,008 comparable households without a birth. Tobacco expenditure falls by about 30 percent within a quarter of expected recognition and does not recover; alcohol falls more gradually, deepens as the pregnancy becomes safer, and returns to its baseline within a quarter of the birth. Purchases of infant furniture and equipment are small while the first trimester lasts, then rise nearly twenty-fold, with more than half of all such spending compressed into the three months before the expected birth month, and the response is concentrated in first births. Household textiles and other home readiness goods peak in the third trimester and revert at the birth, out-of-town travel falls only at the birth, and food at home does not move. The paper also documents that clothing bought for an unborn child is partly recorded as gifts in the survey, a measurement feature with implications for any study of prenatal spending.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11331338/v1
Primary Topic
Gender, Labor, and Family Dynamics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

De Gustibus Gravidarum: Pregnancy, Stable Preferences, and the Four Clocks of Household Demand

Aras Yolusever
Research Square
Gender, Labor, and Family Dynamics
preprint

De Gustibus Gravidarum: Pregnancy, Stable Preferences, and the Four Clocks of Household Demand

Aras Yolusever
preprint en

Abstract

Pregnancy is the hardest case for the Stigler–Becker doctrine that tastes are stable and that observed changes in demand reflect changes in constraints, prices and household technology. A single before-and-after comparison cannot adjudicate the issue, because any change in a demand vector can be rationalized either by a shift in tastes or by a shift in shadow prices. This paper argues that timing can. Gestation is governed by four clocks that start at different dates and leave different signatures in expenditure: an information clock that starts when the pregnancy is recognized, a physiological clock that runs continuously, an option clock that starts when the risk of pregnancy loss resolves, and a deadline clock that ends at the birth. A household production model with fixed preferences delivers distinct timing predictions for harm goods, food, irreversible child durables and home readiness goods, and a non-identification result for designs that ignore timing. The predictions are tested on 1,164 births identified in the rotating panel of the U.S. Consumer Expenditure Interview Survey (2007–2025), using monthly expenditure records and event-study regressions with household and calendar-month fixed effects against 35,008 comparable households without a birth. Tobacco expenditure falls by about 30 percent within a quarter of expected recognition and does not recover; alcohol falls more gradually, deepens as the pregnancy becomes safer, and returns to its baseline within a quarter of the birth. Purchases of infant furniture and equipment are small while the first trimester lasts, then rise nearly twenty-fold, with more than half of all such spending compressed into the three months before the expected birth month, and the response is concentrated in first births. Household textiles and other home readiness goods peak in the third trimester and revert at the birth, out-of-town travel falls only at the birth, and food at home does not move. The paper also documents that clothing bought for an unborn child is partly recorded as gifts in the survey, a measurement feature with implications for any study of prenatal spending.

Research Square
Istanbul Kültür University (TR)
Gender, Labor, and Family Dynamics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon