The Dilemma of Legal Certainty and Justice in Law Enforcement: A Legal Philosophy Study of the Nenek Minah Case
The Nenek Minah case illustrates the enduring tension between legal certainty and justice in criminal law enforcement. This study examines that tension by analytically distinguishing proof of guilt, the justification for invoking criminal proceedings, and the appropriateness of punishment, while evaluating suspended sentencing (pidana bersyarat) as a mechanism for reconciling both values. Employing a normative legal research method with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches, this study analyses primary and secondary legal materials qualitatively through juridical and philosophical reasoning. The findings demonstrate that legal certainty does not require the mechanical imposition of custodial punishment. Rather, a suspended sentence may accommodate the concrete circumstances of an elderly defendant while preserving legal accountability. Nevertheless, an adjustment at the sentencing stage does not automatically resolve questions of procedural justice arising across the criminal process as a whole. The study concludes that legal certainty and justice must be reconciled through transparent, reasoned justification at each distinct stage of law enforcement: the determination of guilt, the decision to invoke criminal proceedings, and the imposition of sanctions.
Authors
- Vincent Daniel Christian
- Ardianto Wijaya Komala
- Florencia Clarence Indradjaja
- Grace Yustitia Ochta Varartha
Institutions
- Tarumanagara University (ID)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Lex journal kajian hukum dan keadilan
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.25139/lex.v10i4.12833
- Primary Topic
- Indonesian Legal and Regulatory Studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00